Skip navigation
Henry Paulson Video Gallery
CNBC's Oriel Morrison has the latest on the company's portfolio holdings.
The U.S. business community is urging the Obama administration to come out with a strong trade policy with Asia. Kristin...
Debating whether investors should still bet on America, with William Gross, PIMCO; James Pualsen, Wells Capital Manageme...
Warren Buffett's ride on the rails got M&A going this week, with the Fast Money crew.
Discussing whether investors should start taking profits following the jobs report, with Paul McCulley, PIMCO and CNBC's...


Current DateTime: 10:20:44 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 24355697

FEATURED QUIZZES


Current DateTime: 10:20:44 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 33793611
  • The Billionaire BFF's

      Philanthropists. Bridge partners. Hockey players. Which responses are based on facts from Buffett's and Gates' real lives?

  • The Many Myths of Coca-Cola

      Can you tell which statements are true, and which ones are just rumors?

  • Think You Understand Markets?

      We've selected some questions from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority's test of investor knowledge. See how you do ...


Current DateTime: 10:20:44 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 24890560
  • Winterizing Your Portfolio

      If 2009 was the winter of our discontent, will 2010 be a winter wonderland for investors? A lot depends on the recovery—or lack thereof.

  • Investor's Guide to Real Estate

      Some even say the long-awaited recovery is here. Regardless, buyers and sellers alike can profit from our guide.

  • Alternative Investing

      Stocks and bonds? Sure. But it's a big world out there for investors.

powered by digg
After Auto Rescue: Bailout Fund Is Under Fire Again
By: Albert Bozzo, Senior Features Editor | 19 Dec 2008 | 03:22 PM ET
Text Size

The Bush Administration's plan to use TARP funding to aid the auto industry and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson’s latest change of heart over whether to seek the remaining $350 billion generated more confusion and concern about the already controversial emergency spending program.

Though the auto bailout package was widely expected, Paulson’s decision represented another policy reversal, having told CNBC just days ago “we’ve got what we need right now.”

CNBC.com

“My conclusion is that they don't have a long-term strategy, and they're bouncing along from crisis to crisis,” said former FDIC Chairman William Isaac.

Critics in and out of government say the misguided decision to use TARP money for the auto bailout is an abuse of the program and will have negative consequences.

“Using TARP funds to bail out failing companies is incredibly risky and poor public policy, and was not the designated intention of the program when Congress approved it,” said Rep. Jeb Hensarling, a Texas Republican, who voted against the $700 billion TARP fund and is now one of four members of Congress’ oversight committee.

Hensarling and others were quick to add that the auto bailout would lead to similar aid to other sectors.

“This is classic pork," said Tom Schatz, president of Citizens Against Government Waste. “There's going to be a long list, saying, ‘Now help us.’ They’re already lining up.”

Even critics of the TARP, which was rushed into law in the aftermath of the Lehman Brothers [LEHMQ  Loading...      ()   ] bankruptcy filing in mid-September, had been steadfast in saying if money has to be spent at all it should be used in efforts aimed at directly stabilizing the financial system.

Until the auto bailout, all $335 billion of the $350 billion authorized thus far had been committed to financial institutions, from commercial banks like Citigroup [C  Loading...      ()   ] to insurers such as AIG [AIG  Loading...      ()   ] or one-time investment banks like Goldman Sachs [GS  Loading...      ()   ].

“Congress created the TARP not to bail out manufacturing companies but to fix the financial system,” says Isaac. “Regardless of the language, it is clear what the intention was. This is a matter of process. I am deeply troubled."

Paulson, until recently, was thought to agree with that strict interpretation, but was apparently persuaded otherwise by President Bush after Senate Republicans sunk stand-alone legislation backed by Congressional Democrats.

If the auto bailout was troubling, Paulson’s latest policy surprise was confusing.

The Treasury Secretary has changed his mind on the issue more than once. In addition, Democrats in Congress, unhappy over Paulson’s strategy, recently told him they’d reject a request for additional funding, unless they felt like he was doing more to aid housing, particularly in terms of mortgage lending and foreclosure forbearance.

As recently as Wednesday, President-elect Barack Obama seemed to suggest that Paulson wasn’t on the verge of asking for money, saying his team been "in conversations" with the Treasury, but implied a decision was not being discussed.

"At the point they give us some signal this is necessary, then we would evaluate it," added Obama.

But in a statement Friday, Paulson said:  “It is clear…that Congress will need to release the remainder of the TARP to support financial market stability.”

Paulson’s decision to seek funding also caused some debate about the current condition of the financial system, which most agree has been stabilized—even if economic activity is contracting swiftly, and the timing of the request.

“It is clear, however that Congress will need to release the remainder of the TARP to support financial market stability,” the Treasury Secretary said in a statement.

“I don't understand why we need another $350 billion," said Isaac.

“Additional $350 billion in TARP funds needs to be approved now," said Brain Bethune, chief US economist at Global Insight. "We are still in the most treacherous phase of the business cycle, and it would be foolish to leave the Treasury Secretary with no arrows in his quiver."

Though Paulson’s statement also said he would “discuss that process with the congressional leadership and the president-elect's transition team in the near future," approval any time soon seems unlikely, from either the lame duck Congress or the one assuming office in early January.

The Congressional oversight panel will be releasing two key reports next month. The first, due Jan. 9, will be an analysis of the program, while the second, scheduled for January 20, the day of the President’s inauguration, will offer recommendation on regulatory reforms.

The mechanics of the approval process also suggest the same. By law, the Congress has 15 days to decide on an official request. Technically, it has to disapprove, or reject, the request for funds. The president, however, can veto that decision.

There’s also the matter of Paulson’s designated replacement, New York Fed chief Timothy Geithner, whose Senate confirmation, once he’s been officially nominated by the new president, would presumably be swift and sure.

Some observers say Paulson’s move is partly intended to keep the markets calm and show he is reaching out to Congressional Democrats and the Obama team about incorporating their strategic agenda. Getting the ball roll rolling on the next installment is prudent, they say.

“The TARP money is beginning to work its way through the system,” says Scott Talbott, senior vice president of government affairs for The Financial Services Roundtable. “The big X-factor is the economy.”

© 2009 CNBC.com
Tools:
Print EmailAdd This share icon
  • digg share

CNBC HIGHLIGHTS

  • Warren Buffett and Bill Gates spoke to Columbia students, and Buffett made the students a startling offer.
  • Brian L. Roberts
  • For the chief of cable company Comcast, growth has been about making deals – generally very large deals.
  • Some companies may start using insurance to shift carbon risk from their balance sheets to maybe... yours?
  • The president and founder of Genesis Today wants to improve America’s health, and thinks Wal-Mart can help.
  • Switzerland's privacy watchdog is taking legal action to force Google to make changes to its Street View service.
  • A wealthy, distracted Texas driver crashed his million-dollar Bugatti Veyron sports car into a salt marsh, say police.
ADD COMMENTS
Remaining characters


Current DateTime: 01:04:47 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29778428

Current DateTime: 01:04:47 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29779196

Current DateTime: 01:04:47 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29779199

Current DateTime: 01:04:04 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29779198
  Data is a real-time snapshot  *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes
Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and Analysis

© 2009 CNBC, Inc.  All Rights Reserved.
A Division of NBC Universal
Thomson ReutersThomson Reuters