Market Insider
- S&P 500 Down — But Not By Much
- EU Finance Ministers Won't Get Fooled Again
- What's Shaking: Friday's Early Movers
- Stocks Looking Past Europe for a New Driver
- Nuance Doesn’t Live Up to Hype
- Commentary: USPS Stuck in the Past
- Why Is Market So 'Tired' With Good News?
- Investor Optimism At Highest In One Year: Survey
- Chesapeake Spurs Nat Gas Rally
- What Exactly Have Greeks Agreed To?
EDITOR
RSS FEED
Week Ahead: Health Care Could Bruise Stocks in Short Term
CNBC Executive Editor
Health care reform could be a temporary dose of bad medicine for stocks, at least in the immediate term.
![]() |
As the House of Representatives moved toward a vote on a health care reform bill, Wall Street was gaming both the legislation's chance of success and its potential impact on markets.
"Buy if it fails. Sell if it passes. But I don't think it will have any sustained and significant market impact," said Larry Kantor, head of research at Barclay's.
"They're going to tax insurance companies, so they're losers. Small firms with more than 15 employees are going to have to provide health care or they're going to have to pay a fee, so they're hit. One would think hospitals would be winners because hospitals pick up the tab for uninsured people. It's not that there's no change. It's just that there's so much controversy around it, you think it's radical change but it's not that radical," he said.
The House voted was expected to be held Sunday if Democrats could secure enough votes to pass the bill.
"It's going to be razor thin either way," said Dan Clifton, policy analyst at Strategas Research. Clifton said the market's reaction was a bit surprising this week, as health insurance stocks advanced even as the the bill moved closer to a vote. "I didn't expect them to be up 9 percent in a week. You'll probably see them drop if this passes," he said.
"There's nothing positive about the government spending $1 trillion over 10 years, and using capital gains taxes to pay for it. It's going to stifle growth," said Clifton.
Jeffery Saut, Raymond James chief investment strategist, said the market could use the vote as an opportunity to sell into a very overbought condition. "The market is very long in the tooth right here. The New York Stock Exchange overbought indicator is over 90. That's historic," he said noting that's happened 62 times since 1926.
The market slowly drifted higher this past week, closing at an 18-month high. The Dow was up 1.1 percent to 10,741. The Dow slipped 37 points Friday, breaking an eight day winning streak. The S&P 500 rose 9, or 0.9 percent to 1159, and the Nasdaq was up 0.3 percent to 2374. The week's best performing S&P sector was telecom, up 2.4 percent, followed by industrials, up 2.2 percent. Health care was up 1.5 percent. Materials and Energy were the laggards down just under 1 percent.
"We've got almost 90 percent of the stocks in the S&P 500 above their 50-day moving average. It rarely gets that high. The point is that in the very short term, the markets are way overextended and they're looking for a reason to pull back. Whether they pull back next week is question because you have end of quarter window dressing," said Saut.
"The question is does the window dressing turn into undressing if the bill passes," he said.
UBS chief equities strategy Binky Chadha, however, said that aside from a possible immediate reaction, the passage of the bill would not be a negative for stocks.
"Uncertainty is the key issue in the market. Equities is about earnings, but even more I would argue it's about multiple. The multiple responds to uncertainty," he said, adding resolution either way should ultimately help the market higher. Chadha sees the market continuing its upward move and says the S&P could reach 1250 by the report of the April jobs report in early May.
Kantor said the next economic report of importance for the markets, in fact, is the March jobs report. "I do think that employment report on April 2 is going to be key. It wasn't like the last one was strong. It was just not terribly weak. If you don't see something over 100,000 in payrolls, that's going to be a big disappointment and the market's going to have a setback. You need to see significant job growth to keep the markets moving up," he said.
- Actor Clint Eastwood responds to critics over the Chrysler Super Bowl ad and all the controversy.
- Here’s a look at Westminster Kennel Club’s most successful breeds and how much they cost.
- When looking for that next career move, workers need to look at the differences between a start-up and a public firm.
- After enduring the recession, many Baby Boomers say money isn’t the most important thing they hope to leave to their kids.
- The ‘Fast Money’ traders weigh in on fashion related stocks from apparel to footwear to accessories and fragrances.
- Attention, online shoppers. The days of tax-free online shopping may be coming to an end in many states.






















