Wells Fargo, on the other hand, beat estimates on the top and bottom lines but traded lower in the afternoon hours on concerns about a steep drop in mortgage loan growth before ending up slightly at $45.58.
"We own the financials because they are the cheapest stocks with the highest quality management," Nygren told CNBC's "Halftime Report."
A former Morningstar Fund Manager of the Year, Nygren said that financials have held the heaviest weighting in his $13 billion Oakmark Fund for years.
It's a move that is paying off, he said, with his fund outperforming the S&P 500 over the last three-, five- and 10-year periods.
For this investor, it all boils down to the price he's paying for stocks.
"We don't wake up in the morning thinking we want to put money to work in boring industries," he said. "But when you see valuations that are less than book value, less than 10 times earnings, to us that looks really, really attractive compared to a market at about 16 times earnings."
Nygren's current top pick and largest holding is Bank of America, a company that he thinks many still consider the poster child for the housing crisis. "We believe CEO Brian Moynihan was dealt a really bad hand when he took over that company."
Nygren went on to say the company's balance sheet is the best relative to peers and that investors could expect increased return of capital in the form of share buybacks or repurchases.
Another area this bargain-hunter is nibbling at is technology, passing on the more buzzed-about names in social media and instead choosing older, more well-established firms, telling CNBC, "We own the old stuff—Oracle, Microsoft and Intel."
—By CNBC's Katie Young. Follow her on Twitter @KatieCNBC