"This does not belie either improvement in general welfare or in the sense of earnings for sufficient encouragement for people to get back in the labor force," said Mark Hamrick, Washington bureau chief for Bankrate.com.
Read MoreBest jobs for 2014
Professional and business services added the most positions, with 81,000, while retail rose 35,000. Food and beverage contributed 20,000, due mostly to what the BLS described as "employment disruptions at a grocery store chain in New England," an apparent reference to the Market Basket impasse in the Boston area. Health care grew by 23,000, while construction added 16,000.
The job creation was tilted heavily toward full-time positions, which surged by 671,000. Part-time jobs actually fell by 384,000.
An alternative measure that includes those who have quit looking for jobs or are working part time for economic reasons—the underemployed—dropped from 12 percent to 11.8 percent.
Read MoreThe worst jobs for 2014
The report, though largely positive, is unlikely to change the Federal Reserve's direction on monetary policy. The U.S. central bank intends on ceasing its monthlybond-buying program in October, while still keeping short-term interest rates near zero.
However, Chair Janet Yellen's belief that labor force participation eventually will rebound sustained some damage.
"The chances of the cyclical rebound in the participation rate that the Fed expects appear to be receding," Paul Dales, senior U.S. economist at Capital Economics, said in a note. "At some point, the Fed may have to conclude that the unemployment rate is a reasonably accurate measure of the amount of slack."
In recent history, September has been a below-trend month when it comes to employment growth.
In 2012, the month posted 161,000 new jobs at a time when the average had been 179,000, while 2013 saw a 164,000 count as the average had been 197,000, according to Deutsche Bank.
Economists had kept their hopes in check for the month, with an anticipation of 215,000 in a year when the average has been 213,000.
CORRECTION: This version corrects the spelling of Paul Dales' last name and corrects the average number for new jobs creation in 2012. An earlier version had the wrong figure for August's unemployment rate.