Investors really need a wake-up call, advisors say

Fully five years into one of the strongest bull market rallies that Wall Street has ever produced, financial advisors say a large percentage of their clients are still too scarred by the wounds inflicted during the 2008 financial collapse to put their money back to work.

Some are hoarding cash reserves from the sale of a company or an inheritance, fearing the next market correction. Others are too conservative with their portfolio picks or eager to bail on their long-term strategy when volatility strikes—and strike it did in 2014.


Analyzing stock market data
MicroWorks | iStock | Getty Images Plus

Whatever their method of "playing it safe," however, their inability to invest for growth—and block out market noise—is putting a serious hurt on the size of their future nest egg.

"There are some people who have been in the market these last five years and enjoyed an amazing run, but we know that in aggregate, investors were actually exiting the market between 2009 and 2012, which amounts to hundreds of billions of dollars of forgone wealth," said Seth Masters, chief investment officer for AllianceBernstein's Bernstein Global Wealth Management. "This is one of the great bull markets of our lifetimes, and many people missed it."

Read MoreBeware the mutual fund blowup

Indeed, the S&P 500 has produced a nearly 72 percent total trailing return since Oct. 12, 2009.

Getting gun-shy investors off the sidelines requires a different message than it did before the Great Recession, when clients' only concern was boosting returns, said Scott Farber, senior vice president and wealth strategist for U.S. Trust in Miami.

Advisors prep clients for 2015
Advisors prep clients for 2015   

Farber said that as he conducts year-end portfolio reviews through Dec. 31, he'll help clients set short- and long-term financial goals, while giving them tools to minimize risk.

"Clients are still very nervous about investing in the market," said Farber, who spends two-thirds of his time educating clients on the cost of being too conservative and the loss of purchasing power due to inflation.

"If you're managing assets for the long term, you have to be conscious of both," he said.

Read More6 ways to lower the 2014 tax bite

The annual inflation rate, as measured by the Consumer Price Index, currently stands at 1.7 percent. Thus, it is not an immediate threat, but Farber said the natural business cycle suggests it will edge higher over time, which erodes the value of money.

Dividend stocks, commodities and Treasury inflation-protected securities (TIPS) have historically helped protect against the corrosive effects of inflation, while fixed-income assets, primarily bonds, have helped to offset equity market risk.

Government-backed bond yields, however, continue to flirt with record lows, with the benchmark 10-year Treasury returning a paltry 2.3 percent, which has forced investors to seek out riskier income-producing alternatives.

Among them, high-yield corporate bonds, master limited partnerships, real estate investment trusts and business development companies, which invest in or lend to small- and mid-sized companies.

Read MoreRebalancing mitigates market risk

Investors who are unfamiliar with the ever-expanding roster of new and increasingly complex financial products are most likely to sit on their hands, Farber said.

"The No. 1 reason people don't implement our advice is because it's too complicated and they don't understand it," he said. "If you take a child by the hand, open a door to a dark room and tell them to go in and play, they won't, because they don't know what's in there."

Your Wealth: Weekly advice on managing your money

Sign up to get Your Wealth

Please enter a valid email address
Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about about our products and service. Privacy Policy.

He added, "It's the same with investors. As soon as you turn on the light, once they understand what the product or strategy is, they can start making educated decisions."

That's where technology can help, said Melissa Motz, certified financial planner and president of Motz Wealth Management, who uses year-end reviews to reiterate the importance of compounded growth.

Read MorePros and cons of tax-loss harvesting

"I utilize financial planning software to help them see the big picture and how a decision today can impact them down the road," she said. "Specifically, I show them a cash-flow analysis."

Motz also reminds clients that if they leave their money under the mattress, they earn nothing and deplete their principal over time, which is far more risky than stocks and bonds.

"The Great Recession has shaken up a lot of folks, and they don't feel like they can trust the market to perform over the long term." -Melissa Motz, president of Motz Wealth Management

Retirees, in particular, can avoid knee-jerk reactions to the market by keeping at least one year's worth of living expenses in a liquid interest-bearing account. They will thus ensure they won't be forced to liquidate their investments if the market is temporarily down, Motz said.

The best investment plan, however, is one that enables investors to sleep at night, according to AllianceBernstein's Masters. Tolerance for risk differs for everyone.

Read MoreRetiring soon? How to get ready

As such, Masters said, he often counsels fearful clients to implement dollar-cost averaging, whereby they purchase a fixed amount of a specific security on a regular schedule over the course of three to six months. Such a strategy ensures they'll purchase some shares high and some low, which minimizes downside risk.

Ultimately, it's not how much you save or even the stocks you pick that determine whether you'll meet your financial goals, Motz said. It's your ability to set a strategy and stay the course no matter what the market delivers.

"The Great Recession has shaken up a lot of folks, and they don't feel like they can trust the market to perform over the long term," she said. "It is impossible to be perfect with your investment selections. This need to be perfect causes paralysis."