Go Symbol Lookup
Loading...

Knives and Golf Clubs: TSA Gets Slightly Less Crazy

 Text Size  
Published: Tuesday, 5 Mar 2013 | 3:50 PM ET
John Carney By:

Senior Editor, CNBC.com

Getty Images

Last year I had a knife confiscated on a flight from Des Moines, Iowa back to my home in New York City. To call it a knife is almost a stretch. It was a blade less than one inch long that was part of an antique money clip I used to organize my bills.

Now it's sitting wherever stuff confiscated by the TSA goes. Along with the toddler sunscreen I lost on the way to San Diego. And the yogurt confiscated on the way back from San Diego.

About that yogurt. It turned out that my hotel's mini-fridge was set a bit too cold. So one container of yogurt, the one set nearest to the back of the fridge, froze solid. The other two containers maintained their intended state of semi-liquidity.

The TSA allowed in the frozen solid yogurt, apparently because it was a solid. They only confiscated the ones that were the usual consistency of yogurt. The Transportation Security Administration official seemed to have been under the impression that whatever terrorist attack I might be able to accomplish with regular yogurt was rendered impossible by the mini-fridge's cold.

All of which is to say: the TSA is insane. I'm sure that there are plenty of sane people employed by the TSA. Perhaps, individually, not a one of them is actually insane. But collectively, when it acts as an organization, it is without a doubt insane. Its rules, prohibitions, procedures bear only a tiny relationship to transportation or security. Although I won't begrudge them the word administration. They certainly seem to be able to administrate.

Perhaps, however, the TSA is coming to its senses. Today Administrator John Pistole announced at an event in Brooklyn that the rules about what you can or cannot fly with are being loosened. Golf clubs, wiffle ball bats, and even small knives will be allowed on board. Pool cues, hockey sticks, and ski poles too.

While this is somewhat of a relief, the reasoning the TSA gives is annoying. They are doing it to confirm to international standards. But if these things can be safely allowed on board in order to conform to international standards, why on earth were they being banned at all. Do we need Swiss Air to tell us what is dangerous?

The truth is that ever since cockpits were locked following the 9/11 attacks, it has become far harder to highjack an airplane with a knife or a golf club. It's not impossible to do with an explosive. But you just aren't going to have much luck when the pilots are locked inside their cockpit and understand that they won't be sparing anyone's life if they open the door under a threat from a terrorist.

Non-frozen yogurt, however, is still a problem. Best freeze it.

Follow me on Twitter @Carney

 Print
New rules from the TSA on bringing "weapons" such as golf clubs and hockey sticks are slightly less crazy than the last round.

   
Comments

 

More Comments

 
 

Add Comments

 

Your Comments (Up to 1100 characters):

Remaining characters

Your comments have not been posted yet.

Please review your submission to make sure you are comfortable with your entry.

Your Comments:


                
            
            
        

Featured

Contact NetNet

  • Senior Editor covering Wall Street, hedge funds, financial regulation and other business news.

  • Senior writer for CNBC.com, covering the gamut of issues affecting the stock market and the economy.

  • Stephanie Landsman is the line producer of CNBC's 5pm ET show "Fast Money."

Subscribe

Wall Street

  • Alcoa and major banks kick off earnings season in the week ahead, and it may be earnings that stalls out stock-market gains.

  • The Fast Money traders have their eyes on next week's earnings parade, and the FOMC minutes. Also, the outcome of a match-up between Bank of America and Honeywell. And, the final trades of the week.

  • CNBC's Maria Bartiromo discusses the day's top business and financial stories, including the poor jobs number and the market's bounce back off its lows. She also looks ahead to the beginning of earnings season.