Unseasonable weather following three years of warm Januarys and Februarys was another headwind for retailers, said Richard Jaffe, an analyst at Stifel Nicolaus. As the weather improved, sales momentum began to perk up, analysts said.
"No question, the more moderate-income consumer, the Wal-Mart consumer, for example, is more impacted by the tax issues we just discussed," Jaffe said. "The more affluent consumer has been able to sail through February pretty much unscathed, and we saw that in the more affluent retail chains, Nordstrom for example."
Telsey told CNBC's "Squawk on the Street" that it's going to take some time for consumers to adjust to rising payroll taxes, but they will adjust.
Although the majority of retailers reported better-than-expected sales figures in February, the numbers don't give as much insight into the industry as previous months' reports have. Several major retailers stopped releasing their monthly figures this month, including Target, Nordstrom, Kohl's and Macy's.
"They were helpful," Jaffe said. "They're gone, and it puts a little more of a premium on our boots-on-the-ground research."
For investors searching for value, Telsey suggested looking to handbag and accessories luxury retailer Coach. The company's stock has suffered this year on concerns about its foothold in the U.S. market.
"It is a value play," she said. "I think we're seeing a lot of value investors become interested in it with nearly $8 a share in cash, a balance sheet that's very strong, the potential for China to accelerate. It helps to offset some of the weakness and changes that are going on in North America."
Additional News: JC Penney Fires 2,200 as Woes Continue: Report
Additional Views: Wal-Mart Stock Is Fair Valued: Pro
— Written by CNBC's Katie Little. Follow her on Twitter @katie_little_
Disclosure information was not available for Dana Telsey or Richard Jaffe.