JPMorgan Court Win Changes Banks' Liability Picture

JP Morgan headquarters on Park Avenue in New York.
Getty Images
JP Morgan headquarters on Park Avenue in New York.

JPMorgan Chase won a court victory today that may have saved it $769 million dollars. The case could also let other banks off the hook in future fraud suits related to mortgage-backed securities.

FSA Asset Management and subsidiaries of the French bank Dexia sought damages of $774 million for fraud in 65 mortgage-backed securities sold by Bear Stearns, JPMorgan, or Washington Mutual, according to court documents.

FSAM was the original purchaser of the 65 certificates in question. It sold 60 of them to Dexia.

(Read More: 'Too Big to Fail' for Banks Not Solved Yet: Fed Gov. Tarullo)

Judge Jed Rakoff, of the Southern District of New York, threw out all Dexia's claims.

Rakoff's decision was based on an arcane point of law that said fraud claims don't transfer to secondary buyers unless they are specifically assigned.

In the suit, JPMorgan alleged there was no fraud involved. But even if there were, the judge's ruling means that Dexia would be out of luck.

(Read More: The Party Isn't Over Yet: Wall Street's Bank Picks)

The ruling leaves only five certificates in the lawsuit and cuts JPMorgan's liability to an estimated $5.7 million, according to court documents.

JPMorgan declined to comment. Lawyers for the plaintiffs could not be reached.

Rakoff's decision could drastically cut future liabilities related to mortgage-backed securities suits for JPMorgan and other banks.

—By CNBC's Margaret Popper; Follow her on Twitter: @popperm


  • Richard Kovacevich in 2007.

    There were only 20 banks that caused the crisis, and "they're all gone," former Wells Fargo CEO Dick Kovacevich told CNBC.

  • How much the banking industry has changed since the collapse of Lehman Brothers, with Richard Kovacevich, Wells Fargo former chairman and CEO.

  • How much of a game changer is Apple Pay? Max Wolff, Manhattan Venture Partners chief economist, and Hans Morris NYCA, discuss the mobile pay ecosystem and why Apple Pay will succeed where others failed.