GO
Loading...

Barclays cash call could be warning ahead of Lloyds, RBS

Wednesday, 31 Jul 2013 | 12:46 PM ET
The Canary Wharf business district in London.
Simon Dawson | Getty Images
The Canary Wharf business district in London.

Barclays' cash call on Tuesday, aimed at boosting its capital strength and meeting another hefty mis-selling charge, could bode ill for other U.K. banks such as Lloyds, analysts said.

(Read more: Barclays plans $9 billion cash call after mis-selling hit)

U.K. bank stocks took a tumble after Barclays' 5.8 billion pound ($8.8 billion) rights issue, breaking a yearlong rally in which Barclays, Lloyds and Royal Bank of Scotland shares rallied 118 percent, 179 percent and 74 percent, respectively, according to numbers from City Index.

Rumors that Barclays would announce a right issue surfaced over the weekend, but markets still rocked on the news that it was setting aside a further 2 billion pounds ($3 billion) to meet mis-selling claims, on top of the 3.5 billion pounds ($5.3 billion) already allocated.

Barclays said it was assigning 1.35 billion pounds ($2.05 billion) extra to meet claims relating to PPIs (payment protection insurance) and 650 million pounds ($990 million) extra for those relating to insurance rate hedging products.

(Read more: UK banks' scandal bill now costliest ever)

Markets now await half-year earnings from Lloyds, RBS and HSBC on Thursday, Friday and Monday, respectively, to learn whether or not other banks will also have to make extra provisions to boost capital levels, or meet mis-selling claims.

"Barclays has taken 2 billion pound additional mis-selling charges. … This reads negatively for Lloyds (sell) and RBS (hold)," said Ian Gordon, a U.K. bank analyst at Investec, on Tuesday.

Citi strategists Andrew Coombs and Ronit Ghose warned that both Lloyds and RBS might need to make further provisions for mis-selling claims.

"Barclays has utilized 58 percent of its PPI provision, versus Lloyds' 73 percent and RBS' 68 percent, which would seem to imply Lloyds and RBS may yet need to take additional conduct charges, albeit claims at both have been slowing," they said in a research note out on Tuesday.

Gordon said that HSBC could also face additional charges for PPI and interest swap claims, but said that Lloyds was "by far the most exposed on that issue". He added that Lloyds' charges were likely to be in the "hundreds of millions," rather than the $1.35 billion figure faced by Barclays.

Does Barclays offer a warning for banks?
Fredrik Nerbrand, head of global asset allocation at HSBC, discusses the dichotomy between European regulators' push for "safer" banks, while also wanting them to lend more.

However, Mediobanca's Christopher Wheeler forecast that Lloyds could face charges as high as 2 billion pounds, having pencilled in 400 million pounds ($607 million) prior to Barclays' announcement.

"That would hurt [Lloyds'] plans to be at a Basel III 'all-in' core Tier 1 ratio of 9 percent at June, as they targeted when the PRA [Prudential Regulation Authority] announcement on capital came out in June," said Wheeler.

Gordon said that other U.K. banks will not face the same regulatory pressure that is on Barclays to increase its capital ratios.

"My view is that the PRA's new 3 percent-adjusted leverage ratio was a very specific and targeted attack on Barclays—only Nationwide got caught in the crossfire, and it was given additional flexibility/time to comply. The other U.K. banks are not affected," he said.

Gordon added that despite the capital hike, he still saw value in Barclays stock, but less so in Lloyds and RBS.

"Lloyds/RBS appear more fully valued given weak earnings/returns ... and Standard Chartered stands out as by far the cheapest 'U.K.' bank on 2013 earnings, with no credit given for a very different earnings/growth profile," he said.

—By CNBC's Katy Barnato

  Price   Change %Change
BARC
---
LLOY
---
RBS
---
HSBA
---
STAN
---

Banks

  • Discussing loan growth in financials and the drag of litigation on Bank of America's earnings, with Gerard Cassidy, RBC Capital Markets lead banking analyst.

  • Ken Moelis, Moelis & Company founder and CEO, discusses the public debut of his company on the NYSE and explains his boutique investment banking model. "Clients will want the flexibility of an independent, unconflicted advisor," Moelis says.

  • Discussing how to buy in volatile market conditions and the investment banking market, David Katz, Matrix Asset Advisors CIO, and Charles Bobrinskoy, Ariel Investments vice chairman & portfolio manager.