Want a house? See what $1 million gets you

Friday, 6 Sep 2013 | 4:48 PM ET

Along with the cost of college, the cost of housing is rising fast.

Home prices are now up over 12 percent from a year ago, according to several surveys, and even rising mortgage rates do not appear to be slowing the gains very much.

As always, however, all real estate is local, and values vary depending on where you look.

(Read more: Home prices overcome rising rates)

Home values are now rising fastest in the markets where they fell the most. Phoenix, Las Vegas, Atlanta and much of California are seeing annual gains of near 20 percent from a year ago, as fewer foreclosures hit the market and investors outbid each other for what bargains remain.

The greatest price driver, however, is lack of supply. Listings are down across the nation, even in markets not hard-hit by the housing recession.

(Read more: Recovery Watch)

Million dollar homes: 'River Retreat' vs. the 'Waterfall Wonder'
CNBC's Mary Thompson and Jackie DeAngelis look at two different million-dollar homes in different parts of the country. The homes are known as the River Retreat and the Waterfall Wonder. Each home is located in an Ivy League town. Super broker Dolly Lenz, reveals the homes' locations and what you can really get for $1 million. Which home wins?
'Waterfall Wonder' vs. 'Urban Rooftop'
Two $1 million homes in Ivy League towns. CNBC's Jackie DeAngelis looks at the "Waterfall Wonder" while Courtney Reagan tours the "Urban Rooftop." Super broker Dolly Lenz picks the winner.
Million Dollar Homes: 'Stately Estate' vs. 'Urban Rooftop'
What can $1 million buy you? CNBC's Robert Frank and Courtney Reagan look at two homes in Ivy League towns, and super broker Dolly Lenz picks the winner.
Million Dollar Homes: 'Stately Estate' vs. 'Patio Palace'
What can $1 million buy you? CNBC's Robert Frank and Seema Mody look at two homes in Ivy League towns, and super broker Dolly Lenz picks the winner.
Million Dollar Homes: 'Pre-War Condo' vs. 'Stately Estate'
What can $1 million buy you? CNBC's Robert Frank and Kayla Tausche report on 2 properties; one is a pre-war condo in New York City. Super broker Dolly Lenz, picks the best offer.
Million Dollar Homes: 'Colonial Charm vs. Pre-War Condo'
CNBC's Brian Sullivan and Kayla Tausche reports on 2 homes worth $1 million. A pre-war condo in New York City goes against a home with colonial charm. Dolly Lenz, shares her pick.
Million Dollar Homes: 'Colonial Charm' vs. 'Clever Craftsman'
What can $1 million buy you? CNBC's Brian Sullivan and Diana Olick report on 2 $1 million homes near Ivy League schools. Super broker Dolly Lenz picks the best offer.

In Boston, inventories of homes for sale are down 34 percent from a year ago, according to the local Realtors association. In Denver it is much the same. Even in Houston, where housing barely faltered, listings are down 21 percent from a year ago.

Several factors are keeping inventories low.

First, negative home equity. Millions of homeowners are still stuck in place, unable to sell because they owe more on their mortgages than their homes are worth. While more than 3 million homeowners came up from underwater in the past year, 12.2 million are still drowning in mortgage debt, according to a recent report from Zillow.

Confidence, or lack thereof, is also still keeping some sellers sidelined.

"There always is a tendency to time the market, which we know is becoming a little bit harder to do," said Budge Huskey, CEO of Coldwell Banker in an interview on CNBC. "It's an assessment of their overall impressions of the economy. I think there's still a little hesitation. People want to see stronger economic growth, people want to see more progress made toward unemployment rates and just feel better about moving on."

Lack of inventory means it is a seller's market, despite so much hesitance by potential sellers themselves. That will keep home prices strong, unless and until more people decide to list their homes and home builders ramp up production, which they have been so far slow to do.

(Read more: $1 million summer homes)

It begs the question, what is housing worth today, market-to-market? A million dollars may buy a McMansion in Oklahoma, but barely buy a bedroom in Manhattan.

In an effort to gauge differing values, CNBC is trawling the million-dollar market again, this time in a "back-to-school" edition.

Starting on "Squawk Box" this Friday, two reporters will show two homes without disclosing their locations; they will document the interiors, exteriors, marketed features and one unique bonus offered by each home.

Real estate maven Dolly Lenz will decide which house gives buyers a better bang for the buck.

We will then reveal where the two houses are located, and with that added to the mix, Lenz will choose a winner. That house will then go up against the next mystery location on the next show.

(Follow along on Twitter with the hashtag and see the early winners here as well).

By CNBC's Diana Olick. Follow her on Twitter @Diana_Olick.

Questions?Comments? facebook.com/DianaOlickCNBC


  • Diana Olick serves as CNBC's real estate correspondent as well as the editor of the Realty Check section on CNBC.com.

Real Estate Explained