The mistake that's tripling your medical bills

To cut medical bills, consumers should take a leaf from their strategies for other big purchases: Shop around.

Doing so can have a substantial payoff. A Change Healthcare analysis released this spring found that prices can vary by more than 300 percent on the same service, even within a given insurer's network of providers. (See chart below for ranges on some common services.) Sometimes the price gap is even wider.

Another study this year found that giving birth in California might cost as little as $3,000 or as much as $37,000—and that's only for simple vaginal delivery, and after adjusting for factors such as moms who had complications.

Read More What's it cost to have a baby?

Price gaps on medical bills

Price range
Colonoscopy $1,379 to $4,242 208%
CT scan $307 to $2,747 796%
Mammogram $135 to $397 195%
MRI scan $511 to $2,815 451%
Physical therapy office visit $62 to $228 268%
Psychiatrist office visit $55 to $176 219%
Tooth extraction $79 to $195 147%
Vaginal delivery $4,359 to $12,613 189%
SOURCE: Q4 2013 prices from Change Healthcare Corporation's Healthcare Transparency Index.

Don't think that being insured gives you license to get complacent. With more plans entailing high deductibles and other out-of-pocket costs, big price swings still matter, said Dr. Davis Liu, author of "The Thrifty Patient."

Take that example of giving birth in California. Before factoring in deductibles or copay, a plan that covers 85 percent of the costs of hospitalization—which isn't unusual—might mean new parents are responsible for $450, or up to $5,550.

Check out the video above for tips on getting a better price. Of course, it's not smart to go by price alone. "Make sure you're not compromising on quality of care," said Liu. To do that get details from your doctor about say, what kind of imaging technique is preferable for that MRI, or qualities needed to pick a good physical therapist. Then look at ratings and reviews.

The Leapfrog Group maintains a database of hospital safety scores, while doctor ratings can be found on sites including RateMDs and Healthgrades.

By CNBC's Kelli B. Grant

Contact Digital Workshop


    Get the best of CNBC in your inbox

    To learn more about how we use your information,
    please read our Privacy Policy.
    › Learn More

Ask the Car Chasers

Off the Cuff

Big Data Download

Selling the American Dream

Death & Dishonor: Crisis at the VA

  • A pedestrian walks past the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) headquarters in Washington, D.C.

    The Veterans health care system has come under fire as officials reap big bonuses while patients suffer. CNBC's Dina Gusovsky investigates.

  • America has the highest incarceration rate in the world, and that opens up the door for companies to have a captive market -- literally. One of those companies is JPay, which provides electronic money transfers and other services to about 70 percent of state prisons. But in order to get that lucrative state prison contract, the state takes a commission as well. Critics argue all the costs are passed down to families and inmates, often burdening them financially. CNBC's Dina Gusovsky Reports.

  • This photo shows the aftermath of the accident, including the burned out shell of a truck. The Lindner minivan was so crushed its wreckage cannot be seen.

    Fatal truck accidents happen nearly 11 times a day. CNBC looks at the causes, who's to blame, and why it gets little attention.