Supreme Court to Hear Suit Against Stock Brokers

The Supreme Court agreed to consider a lawsuit against major Wall Street firms accused of conspiring to manipulate prices on newly issued shares during the stock market boom of the 1990s.

A federal court dismissed the suit brought by investors, but the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reinstated it.

The issue is whether Wall Street banks are immune from antitrust liability in this instance because much of the alleged conduct is either permitted under federal securities law or not specifically prohibited.

The investors say the firms colluded to force “tie-ins” on investors, compelling them to pay a premium for highly sought-after shares in a company. The investors also say they were pressured by the firms into agreeing ahead of time to buy additional shares at a higher price.

In papers filed with the court, lawyers for the Bush administration say the investment banks are incorrect in asserting that implied immunity from antitrust liability shields all conduct relating to new stock offerings.

At the same time, the administration says the appeals court ruling against the Wall Street firms failed to take into account legitimate collaboration between the banks.

The defendants are 16 of the country’s largest underwriters and institutional investors.

The case is Credit Suisse v. Glen Billing, 05-1157.

Contact U.S. News


    Get the best of CNBC in your inbox

    Please choose a subscription

    Please enter a valid email address
    To learn more about how we use your information,
    please read our Privacy Policy.

Don't Miss

  • The Glass Ceiling

    Full-time working women still only earn about 77% of what men do in the same fields. A lawsuit in Silicon Valley is bringing renewed focus to that statistic. Vanity Fair Contributing Editor Bethany McLean on the equality fight for women's pay and promotion.

  • Man takes off work clothes on beach

    With Ruth Porat leaving Wall Street for Silicon Valley, Turney Duff takes a look at other ex-Wall Street friends and where they are now.

  • A group of scientists believe they've cracked the reason behind a big mystery: Why are beards so popular?

U.S. Video