Enter multiple symbols separated by commas

Supreme Court Rules For MedImmune in Patent Suit Against Genentech

The U.S. Supreme Court sided with MedImmune and reinstated the company's lawsuit challenging the validity of a key Genentechpatent.

In a decision closely watched by U.S. patent experts, the high court voted by a margin of 8-1 to reverse a federal appeals court. The suit was aimed at overturning a Genentech patent covering a method of producing antibody drugs.

The case was sent back to the appeals court for further proceedings.

The patent at issue in the case, known as the Cabilly patent, is licensed by MedImmune in connection with its biggest-selling product, a respiratory drug called Synagis.

The case also has broader implications for the U.S. patent system because it raises the question of whether companies should be allowed to sue to invalidate a patent while they continue to license it.

Such lawsuits have been blocked in the past by the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, a U.S. court that specializes in hearing patent cases.

The federal circuit appeals court has held that companies cannot sue to invalidate a patent they are licensing because they have "no reasonable apprehension" of being sued for infringement.

But Justice Antonin Scalia, writing the majority opinion, disagreed, saying licensing a patent should not preclude a challenge to that patent.

"Promising to pay royalties on patents that have not been held invalid does not amount to a promise not to seek a holding of their invalidity," Scalia wrote.

The lone dissent from the ruling came from Justice Clarence Thomas.

The case has prompted concerns among brand name drug makers and other patent-reliant companies, who expressed concerns that a ruling in favor of MedImmune could harm the patent system and disrupt licensing deals.

Genentech is majority owned by Roche Holding.

Contact U.S. News


    Get the best of CNBC in your inbox

    Please choose a subscription

    Please enter a valid email address
    To learn more about how we use your information,
    please read our Privacy Policy.

Don't Miss

  • The California property that once served as Michael Jackson's home and personal fantasyland is being listed at $100 million.

  • Lottery ticket

    A thief who broke into the car of a Seattle couple left behind a million-dollar lottery ticket, NBC News reports.

  • The Lamborghini SpA Urus SUV.

    There's no shortage of luxury vehicle choices, but increasingly the wealthy are opting for high-end SUVs instead of traditional models.

U.S. Video

  • Rates... what's normal? 3% the new 6%: Ed Keon

    This is a fundamental supply and demand story, says Ed Keon, QMA managing director, sharing his outlook on bond yields and demand for fixed income products.

  • This Day in History, May 29

    On this day in history, in 1978 first class postage increases to 15 cents, Columbia Records fires Clive Davis in 1979, and in 1992, Apple unveils the Newton MessagePad.

  • Hillary Clinton's next move

    CNBC's John Harwood reports the latest details on Hillary Clinton's campaign and her strategy for the 2016 presidential race.