Skip navigation
MOST POPULAR RELATED TAGS
  • TOPICS
  • SECTORS
  • COMPANIES

Current DateTime: 04:20:18 12 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 24355697
powered by digg
See all Play-by-Play postsSee all Morning Call posts
Text Size
Jan.23
12:32 PM ET
Tuesday, 23 Jan 2007
Social Security "Crisis" -- Still Real Or "Nonsense?"

AP

Few would argue with the White House’s Web site, when it calls the U.S. Social Security system “one of the great moral successes of the 20th century.”

But much has changed since President Franklin D. Roosevelt founded the system in 1935 – including a historically huge graying population. And that’s where the debates start.

Grover Norquist, president of Americans for Tax Reform, told CNBC’s Michelle Lee he believes “the FICA [payroll tax] crisis is now, not 25 years from now.” He says that private investment accounts -- championed by [the George W. Bush administration] – are the best solution to the so-called crisis, pointing to nations including Chile and Britain that utilize the accounts.  He thundered that Democratic opponents of Republican Social Security policies constitute “a party of tax collectors” -- who dread the idea of every American being a stockholder.

Counterpoint: Dean Baker, co-director of the Center for Economic and Policy Research, joined the “Morning Call” fray to declare that, “the idea that there’s a ‘crisis’ is nonsense.” He said Norquist’s thesis of a Social Security collapse just doesn’t add up mathematically (see below) – and warned that the argument for private accounts is based on “unrealistic” stock-market assumptions.

According to the White House site, there were 16 workers to support every one Social Security recipient during the Harry S Truman administration. But today, there are a mere 3.3 workers supporting every beneficiary. And “By the time today’s youngest workers turn 65, there will only be two workers supporting each beneficiary.”

FYI: Social Security is a big source of income for elderly Americans, providing the majority of income for two-thirds of elderly beneficiaries and all of the income for 20% of them. According to the most recent report by the Trustees of Social Security, even under the cautious assumption that the U.S. economy grows at the anemic rate of 1.6% a year, the revenues into Social Security from the current level of payroll taxes will cover promised benefits for another 38 years and will be enough to finance about 70% of benefits through 2078.

The net present value of the shortfall in revenues over the next 75 years is $3.7 trillion, only about one-third of the net present value of the Bush tax cuts of 2001 and 2003 and about 0.7% of gross domestic product projected for the same period. An immediate payroll tax increase of about 2% would eliminate this gap. So would paring the Bush tax cuts of 2001 and 2003 back by less than 50%, and transferring the added revenues to Social Security. (source: BusinessWeek)


Tools:
PrintEmailAdd This share icon
  • digg share

CNBC HIGHLIGHTS

  • Warren Buffett and Bill Gates spoke to Columbia students, and Buffett made the students a startling offer.
  • They may have wrecked their companies or saved our economy. Tell us what you think.
  • Big pharma embraces social media, but how much should a tightly regulated sector say on Facebook or Twitter?
  • A European dating site finds lovelorn singles from one country to be consistently uglier. Which is it?
  • Contributor David Pogue looks at two of the latest efforts to perfect the digital pocket camera.
  • PepsiCo is ramping up its onsite health facilities for workers.
ADD COMMENTS
Remaining characters


Current DateTime: 02:33:18 12 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29778428

Current DateTime: 11:27:46 12 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29779196

Current DateTime: 04:10:05 12 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29779199

Current DateTime: 01:00:12 12 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29779198
  Data is a real-time snapshot  *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes
Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and Analysis

© 2009 CNBC, Inc.  All Rights Reserved.
A Division of NBC Universal
Thomson ReutersThomson Reuters