Wal-Mart's Critics Grow, Raising Questions About CEO Lee Scott

A poll released today by activist group Wal-Mart Watch shows that Wal-Mart’s favorable rating has dropped to 71% since 2005. With the retailer facing criticism about poor stock performance, disappointing sales and the corporate spying scandal, is it time for CEO Lee Scott to go? Jon Ogg, editor at 24/7 Wall Street and Maggie Gilliam, former retail analyst and president of Gilliam & Company, debated the issue today on Power Lunch.

“ ‘Always low prices’ is not supposed to be about your stock price," said Ogg, who believes that Wal-Mart needs a new face. “In the last five years the Dow is up more than 50% off its lows and Wal-Mart’s stock is flat. It’s just not working. Everything they do does not work," said Ogg.

However, Gilliam points out that global sales were up 12%.

“Globally sales were up and sales domestically have been a little disappointing, but there were still up over $16 billion last year in the Wal-Mart division alone," said Gilliam. “I don’t think Lee Scott is on the way out by any stretch of the imagination.”

Contact Power Lunch

  • Showtimes

    United States
    Monday - Friday 1:00P ET
    Monday - Friday 18:00 CET
    Asia Pacific
    Tuesday - Saturday 01:00 SIN/HK
    Tuesday - Saturday 03:00 AEST
  • Sue Herera is a founding member of CNBC, helping to launch the network in 1989. She is co-anchor of "Power Lunch."

  • "Power Lunch" & “Nightly Business Report” Co-Anchor

Power Pitch

Kenny Polcari