GO
Loading...

Enter multiple symbols separated by commas

What's Behind All the Surprises in Corporate Earnings

Can earnings guidance be trusted? Firms as disparate as Caterpillar, Cummins, Yahoo! and Research in Motion all beat first-quarter earnings expectations.

David Dropsey, equity research analyst at Thomson Financial, and Dirk van Dijk, director of research at Zacks Investment Research, gave "Power Lunch" viewers their perspectives on the apparent data gap.

Van Dijk told CNBC's Bill Griffeth that analysts should have expected the quarterly outcomes: "It's the same situation over and over again," he declared.

The research director pointed out that in 2006, each quarter had "far more positive surprises than disappointments," beating views by 3% to 3.5%.

"Lo and behold, it's almost identical this time," Van Dijk said: Excluding tech firms, the median of all who reported came in at 2.9% over expectations. He believes that "companies have discovered it's better to under-promise and over-deliver."

Dropsey said that earnings "stats are accurate," especially for the first quarter. He explained the surprises as "a lack of positive guidance" -- due to "analyst and executives alike" who "didn't want to get caught up in a slowdown."

He believes that "analysts were playing into fear and keeping their numbers down" to avoid looking "foolish."

Symbol
Price
 
Change
%Change
VOW3
---
CMI
---
BB
---
YHOO
---

Contact Power Lunch

  • Showtimes

    United States
    Monday - Friday 1PM-3P ET

Power Pitch

  • Alan Knuckman uses bone-in chicken thighs for his healthier version of the “rib”

    This start-up says it's cooking up a healthier, convenient version of barbecue ribs.

  • Parche takes your keys and takes care of parking your car

    Parche founder Christian Peneff pitches his valet start-up in 60 seconds. Will the panel get behind the wheel?

  • Female Running with AMPY charger

    AMPY co-founders Alex Smith and Tejas Shastry pitch their start-up to a panel of experts on CNBC.