More Videos
- My Top 10 Tech Toys for the Holidays
- iPhone a Better Gaming Platform Than Android?
- Dell Has Some Explaining to Do
- Dell May Start to Show Some Promise
- Has Twitter's Finest Hours (Seconds) Come and Gone?
- Intel's Andy Bryant Offers An Explanation
- Apple's Global Retail Invasion
- Intel Settles; AMD Settles the Score
- HP's Shot Across Cisco's Bow
- Back Off, Regulators!
MOST SHARED
- Wall Street Finds Profits by Reducing Mortgages
- CNBC VIDEO: Warren Buffett & Bill Gates 'Walk & Talk' at Columbia University
- Kraft Weighs Higher Cadbury Bid as Rivals Circle
- MBS Buyback Program Should be Extended: Fed's Bullard
- China Wind Power Reportedly Seeking $2.2 Billion in IPO
- Volkswagen to Triple China Sales by 2018
- China Should Stop Property Stimulus Now: Central Bank
- Schork Oil Outlook: Mission Impossible For The Bears?
- S&P Stocks Trading at New 52-Week Highs
- Losey: Asset Allocation At Retirement
- Farrell: Obama Hectored, Ignored and Restricted?
- Don't Dwell on Investment Mistakes; Move on, Like Buffett
- CNBC VIDEO: Warren Buffett & Bill Gates 'Walk & Talk' at Columbia University
- U.S. Stocks Slip, Dollar Rises
- How Stock Investors Can Play Holiday Travel
- Time Lapse World Series Is A Great Play
- Wave of Debt Payments Facing US Government
- US Job Losses to Bottom out Next Quarter: NABE
- Obama Jobs Forum May Be More Political Than Practical
- Late Payments on Credit Cards Drop in Third Quarter
- Smallest US Businesses Borrowing Again: PayNet
- China Asks Its Banks to Slow Down Lending
- Little Sign of Inflation on the Horizon: IMF
- Kraft Weighs Higher Cadbury Bid as Rivals Circle
- MBS Program Should be Extended: Fed's Bullard
RSS FEED
Tech Check
Text Size 
The news appeared dire: a web report of serious problems connected to Apple's iPhone and the stock gets whacked. No, that's not a story from today. That news harkened back to June 3 when the website engadget.com reported erroneously of an internal Apple memo purporting to show that iPhone's launch would be delayed six months.
That day, as that "news" broke, my Blackberry went crazy, the phones starting ringing off the hook. "Get in the (anchor) chair," I was told. "News breaking!" What was it, I asked? "iPhone delays." Was it confirmed? "It's on the web." Great. Was it confirmed? Give me ten minutes, I said. You don't have ten minutes, I was told. Stock's reacting.
 |
It took me five minutes to reach Apple spokesman Steve Dowling who asked for more time to see what was going on. I told him you have two minutes, as I put on my microphone and plugged in my earpiece.
He called 90 seconds later. I asked him if there were a Post-it note on his monitor telling him he was about to have a bad day. "No," he said. "That memo is a fake. iPhone is on time."
I went with the story 20 seconds later. The stock instantly recovered and even went positive. And the story was retracted. It took a few minutes, but the story -- our story -- was accurate.
Flash forward to today: reports -- rumors -- of an Apple production problem that could cut iPhone manufacturing in half, from 9 million units this quarter to 4.5 million from the website thestreet.com.
Apple's stock [AAPL
Loading...
()
] tanks. Hard. Three percent. Five percent. Seven percent. Thestreet.com's reporter Scott Moritz writes: "The chatter that sent the stock down was that Apple was reducing its production of iPhones from '9 million units to 4.5 million units' according to a note from the stock trading desk at Miller Tabak & Co.
"The trading note, issued in an attempt to explain why Apple shares were down in heavy volume despite a lack of apparent news, cites talk on Wall Street and also points to speculation that the cuts may be coming in iPod production."
 |
Manuel Balce Ceneta |
Sounds intense. If it were true.
The note reportedly came from trader Peter Boockvar. I called him this evening and he not only distanced himself from the note, but says there never was one. No alert. No broad warning to clients or traders of any kind. Turns out one trader was communicating with one
client via email and when asked whether he had heard of the rumors, Boockvar said yes and from then on, the "news" was attributed to his firm.
"We weren't issuing any kind of report," Boockvar tells me. "We don't have an Apple analyst. We don't even have a tech analyst!"
But the damage was done. I got a mention of this on at the end of Closing Bell near 5 p.m. EDT today. Trouble was, the trading day was already done, and Apple investors saw $8 billion in market cap wiped away because of what seems like overly aggressive reporting that turned out not to be true.
I'm all for aggressive. I'm all for peeling back the PR white-wash that can dominate tech news from time to time. I'm all for working fast and being tough. I'm also all for being fair; and mostly, I'm all for being right. I've made my fair share of mistakes. You can't do this job properly without making mistakes. Even the best basketball and water polo and hockey players commit fouls and penalties when they play the game.
But today's coverage of Apple just seemed sloppy. And sadly, the company and its shareholders paid the price. I talked with another trader at Miller Tabak who told me he was just stunned at what happened today. How simple conversation between one individual and
another could instantly be blown so far out of proportion. And for no apparent reason. He was shocked.
Today's Apple action is a wrenching reminder that investors can no longer be content simply considering the source. Investors have to take matters into their own hands and do some research of their own.
Especially with journalistic lines so blurred nowadays between TV, internet, newspapers, and blog; all of whom proclaiming their legitimacy, accuracy and relevance. I'm not proclaiming my perfection; or even CNBC's. I've copped to mistakes I've made. And that's the lesson here: we all make mistakes.
It's just that this one could've easily been avoided with a little more attention paid to "journalism," and a little less paid to the "noise." Type first and ask questions later doesn't work in print, on the air, or even online.
Apple should be an interesting play on Wednesday. It's almost like the company's going to be on sale: 7% off!
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes