Skip navigation
What Do You Say

More Heat



Current DateTime: 03:23:20 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 24355697
powered by digg
See More of The HeatAbout the HeatSee More of The Heat
Text Size
Aug.18
10:22 AM ET
Saturday, 18 Aug 2007
Did the Fed Do the Right Thing?

Ben Bernanke: The Right Move?

Wall Street's mood is significantly better now than it has been in recent days, after the Federal Reserve surprised the markets by cutting its discount rate by an aggressive half-percentage point, from 6.25% tp 5.75%.

CNBC's Jim Cramer came on Squawk on the Street at the open Friday celebrating the Fed's move ("They nailed it!") for fending off what he thinks would have been a thousand-point Dow plunge and and predicting "we will be up the most (Dow points) we've ever been in history today."  (Of course, who can forget Cramer's 'They know nothing' rant of just two weeks ago, calling for a Fed rate cut?)

Stocks did indeed respond.  After an opening surge of 300 points, the Dow ended with a gain of 233 points.  Not the best ever, but nothing for the bulls to complain about.

(If you're still feeling jittery, check out our special "Survival Guide Edition" of The Heat.)

To be clear, we're talking about the discount rate (direct loans to banks), not the more important federal funds rate (overnight loans between banks.) The Fed's target there remains at 5.25%, where's its been for more than a year.

But, at least for now, the markets are taking the move as a strong signal that Ben Bernanke and Company are on the job and ready to do what it takes to prevent catastrophe in the wake of the confidence crisis that emerged in the credit market in the wake of the subprime mess.

Just last week, the Heat asked, "Should the Federal Reserve come to the rescue of the financial markets by cutting interest rates?"  Your responses were unusually emotional.

Now, The Heat asks: Did the Federal Reserve do the right thing by cutting the discount rate?

  We've heard from 50 of Wall Street's top strategists, money managers and economists on the same question.  The results of our Trillion Dollar Snap Survey show an overwhelming majority, 96%, of those responding think Bernanke got it right.

Here you can find the facts and opinions you need to make up your own mind . . . and tell us what you think.

Briefing Book: From CNBC

CNBC.com:  Fed Cuts Discount Lending Rate in Surprise Move (August 17)

CNBC.com: Stocks Close Broadly Higher After Fed Cuts Discount Rate (August 17)

CNBC.com: Market Outlook- More From The Fed (August 17)

Squawk on the Street Video Clip: Former Federal Reserve Governor Lyle Gramley on the Fed's move (August 17)

Faber Report Video Clip: Why Deals Will Still Get Done (August 17)

Reuters on CNBC.com: Dollar Falls after Fed Cuts Discount (August 17)

CNBC Trillion Dollar Snap Survey: Wall Street Pros Say Fed Did Right Thing (August 17)

CNBC.com: Pisani's Trader Talk- Fed Cut Shifts Rumor Mill Into Overdrive (August 17)

CNBC.com: Text of Federal Reserve Statement (August 17)

Reuters on CNBC.com: What is the Fed's Discount Window? (August 17)

Briefing Book: From Around the Web

Wall Street Journal: Fed Offers Banks Loans Amid Crisis (August 18)

New York Times: Fearing Slide in Economy, Fed Cuts Its Discount Rate (August 18)

Financial Times: Fed brings relief to the markets  (August 18)

American Public Media's Marketplace Radio Program: The Fed prescribes... relaxed credit (August 17)

Forbes.com: Everybody Loves a Discount (August 17)

Opinions

Squawk on the Street Video Clip: Jim Cramer Applauds Fed's Discount Rate Cut (August 17)

James Altucher on TheStreet.com: Rate Cut Mea Culpa and Hats Off to Cramer (August 17)

UrbanDigs.com: Ben Bernanke's "Amazing Job" (August 17)

RushLimbaugh.com: Drive-Bys Stoke Market Plunge (August 16)

The Heat's Opinion

The Heat said last week that it "wouldn't bet against" the market's growing expectations of a rate cut in "the next few months," but has to admit it was thinking about the benchmark Fed Funds target rate, rather than the Discount Rate.

Now the markets are still expecting a Fed Funds rate cut, and will be very disappointed if they don't get it.

The Heat hopes that the central bank's addition of a little more booze to the punch bowl at what's been a somewhat irresponsible party, won't leave us all with a bigger hangover in the morning.

Questions?  Comments? 


Did the Fed do the right thing in cutting the discount rate?

Email us at:

"Cutting the discount rate was a good move by the Fed to provide liquidity, but I believe it was wrong to announce it before the open today. Providing liquidity to keep the credit market functioning is one thing, but intentionally demolishing the shorts in the index futures options shows a bias. The Fed should want properly functioning markets and have no bias to their direction. The cut announcement could have been made after the market opened today." - Eddie, Mississippi

"If anyone thinks that the Fed move solves any of the problems in the economy, they are dreaming. This economy is headed into trouble. As for the stock market, can you imagine what is going to happen when the homebuilders and the financials report greatly reduced earnings or even losses?" - Ken L.

"Anyone who would not agree that this was the right thing to do simply is not looking at the markets and is too young to be instructed about markets. Of course it was exactly the right thing to do in a process of actions that we should all expect/hope is in the mind of the Chairman. The ship is being steered properly and by the absolutely perfect captain. The market needed to, and still needs to, squeeze out some of the excesses that existed in the mortgage markets, especially the subprime segment. We are going to be okay and move on just fine." -  Sam T.

"Ben met with George. George told Ben to do something to make sure the rich get richer and the poor stay poor. So Ben did what George told him to do. Now all of the stupid mistakes that all the dumb mortgage companies and banks have been making are erased with one stroke of the pen. Now all of you 'news people' can continue to tell all of the sheep that are pouring their money into the market that 'all is well again and there are no problems.'" -  Michael R.

"Bernanke me this? Would you cut the Fed Funds rate when the markets are behaving like the world is coming to an end? I don't think so! The discount rate was the right thing to do! GO FOMC!" - Joseph P. C. 

"The Fed did the right thing but it is not enough. They have been injecting liquidity and now they have to cut the discount rate. Now, I hope they lower the Fed Funds rate." - David T.

"The financial community is clamoring for lower short-term borrowing rates from the Fed. They warn about a credit-crunch and a sudden withdrawal of cash availability from our economy. At the same time, they inappropriately continue the avalanche of credit card offers to consumers on a daily basis and charge 20% to 30% or more on outstanding balances. If the financial community would be willling to exercise a little more discretion when issuing credit cards, forego their current windfall and accept a paltry 8% to 12% return on outstanding balances, the resulting infusion of cash into our economy would be trememdous."  - Tim O.

"Chair Bernanke made a courageous and right minded decison by effecting a discount rate cut. Given the propensity for continued global expansion, inflation remains a concern. Cutting the discount rate reduces the expectation for renewed inflation pressures while simultaneously freeing up capital flows. Kudos to The Chair." - Bruce G.

"The Fed has sided with the reckless bulls. It is taking sides (playing dirty) on a triple-witching day. They MUST be fired." - Sanjay, Orange County

"I think the cut of the discount rate was perfect. It buys the Fed time to consider a much wider range of issues before they go with an official rate cut, which may be unnecessary." - Don R., Miami, FL

"While it was probably wise for the Fed to cut the discount rate, doing it when it did was pure manipulation of the market to get the desired outcome the Fed wanted. Knee-jerk monetary policy? Give me a break!" - Harvey F.

"Nothing more than an attempted bailout." - Timothy D.

"Well, Messrs. Cudlow and Cramer got what they wanted - a Fed bailout of the market risk takers. However, I hope they don't forget that for every winner there's a loser. The loser in this case are those Americans who chose to invest in 'safe' U.S. Dollar denominated investments like bank CD's, Treasuries, etc. Unfortunately, it's always the 'big boy's club' that has the upper hand and it looks like they won again. For those who believed in safety and soundness and chose to avoid risk, they will continue to see their life savings dwindle away as their U.S. dollars buy less and less both at home and around the world." -  Alan, South Carolina

"I think the Fed did the right thing to lower the discount rate as a temporary fix to the liquidity problem." - Roger S.

READ MORE COMMENTS


Tools:
PrintEmailAdd This share icon
  • digg share

CNBC HIGHLIGHTS

  • Warren Buffett and Bill Gates spoke to Columbia students, and Buffett made the students a startling offer.
  • Brian L. Roberts
  • For the chief of cable company Comcast, growth has been about making deals – generally very large deals.
  • Some companies may start using insurance to shift carbon risk from their balance sheets to maybe... yours?
  • The president and founder of Genesis Today wants to improve America’s health, and thinks Wal-Mart can help.
  • Switzerland's privacy watchdog is taking legal action to force Google to make changes to its Street View service.
  • A wealthy, distracted Texas driver crashed his million-dollar Bugatti Veyron sports car into a salt marsh, say police.
ADD COMMENTS
Remaining characters


Current DateTime: 01:08:03 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29778428

Current DateTime: 01:04:47 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29779196

Current DateTime: 01:04:04 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29779199

Current DateTime: 01:02:14 14 Nov 2009
LinksList Documentid: 29779198
  Data is a real-time snapshot  *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes
Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and Analysis

© 2009 CNBC, Inc.  All Rights Reserved.
A Division of NBC Universal
Thomson ReutersThomson Reuters