Skip navigation
MOST POPULAR RELATED TAGS
  • TOPICS
  • SECTORS
  • COMPANIES
Trader Talk Video Gallery
CNBC's Bob Pisani takes a look at new Gulf state ETFs.
Bob Pisani reports on the trading day from the NYSE
Bob Pisani reports on the trading day from the NYSE
Financial stocks continue to rally, but is it for real? Rick Schottenfeld, of the Schottenfeld Group, and CNBC's Bob Pis...
Bob Pisani reports on the trading day from the NYSE
How to make money investing in this market, with Steven Sanders, First Genesis Financial; David Kotok, Cumberland Adviso...
Bob Pisani reports on the trading day from the NYSE
Bob Pisani reports on the trading day from the NYSE
See all Trader Talk posts
Font size:
Mar.24
11:55 AM ET
Monday, 24 Mar 2008
Analyst Estimates: So Just How Good Are They?

Ever wonder how good analyst estimates are? The Street watches them all the time, because...uh, there's no other game in town when it comes to projecting estimates.

The general belief among veteran traders and stock market reporters (myself included) is that the analysts tend to overinflate the earnings estimates of the companies they cover. They do this because being excessively bearish usually guarantees little if any access to the company, and the analysts assume that being more bullish will help their company provide financial services to the company they cover.

Now, along comes a study from Penn State professors Patrick Cusatis and M. Randall Woolridge which concludes (surprise!) that "long-term EPS growth rate projections are consistently overly-optimistic." From 1984 to 2006, the analysts' average one-year per-share earnings expectations were for 13.8 percent growth; average actual growth rate was 9.8 percent.

The only time analysts under-estimate earnings growth rates is for short periods of earnings recoveries after economic recessions, and in that case they are too bearish. That, by the way, is about where we are right now.

  related content


Questions?  Comments? 

© 2008 CNBC, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Permalink: /id/23779415

HOME  |  NEWS  |  MARKETS  |  EARNINGS  |  INVESTING  |  VIDEO  |  CNBC TV  |  CNBC PLUS  |  CNBC HD+
About CNBC   |   Site Map   |   Privacy Policy   |   Terms of Service   |   Advertise   |   Help   |   Feedback   |   Video Reprints
  Data is a real-time snapshot   *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes

Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and Analysis