Skip navigation
Trader Talk Video Gallery
Checking the markets, with Peter Kenny, Knight Equity Trading; Peter Costa, NYSE floor trader; and CNBC's Bob Pisani & E...
Bob Pisani reports on the trading day from the NYSE
Technical trading analysis, with Scott Redler, T3Live.Com; Gordon Charlop,Rosenblatt Securities market analyst; and CNBC...
Insight on Treasury Secreatry Henry Paulson's comments, with CNBC's John Harwood, Steve Liesman, Rick Santelli, Phil LeB...
Insight on Treasury Secreatry Henry Paulson's comments, with CNBC's John Harwood, Steve Liesman, Rick Santelli, Phil LeB...
Why financials keep dropping, with CNBC's Bob Pisani.
Debating whether there is more pain to come, with Neil Hennessy, Hennessy Funds and CNBC's Bill Seidman & Bob Pisani.
Bob Pisani reports on the trading day from the NYSE.
See all Trader Talk posts
Text Size

The big discussion today revolves around the continuing route in commodity stocks...the decline is so steep and severe that it is fueling theories that a liquidation is occurring due to: 1) another commodity firm going out of business (most likely), 2) prime brokers telling clients they don't want them in commodities, or 3) firms that lend in the commodity markets pulling back.

Just look at the last two days: Freeport McMoran [FCX  Loading...      ()   ]down 11 percent, Potash [POT  Loading...      ()   ]down 11 percent, U.S. Steel [X  Loading...      ()   ]down 11 percent, Barrick Gold [ABX  Loading...      ()   ]down 9 percent.

And that's just metals and agriculture. In energy, Arch Coal[ACI  Loading...      ()   ] down almost 25 percent, Foundation Coal [FCL  Loading...      ()   ]down 16 percent, Bucyrus [BUCY  Loading...      ()   ]and Joy Global[JOYG  Loading...      ()   ] (mining equipment) both down about 25 percent.

Oil service stocks are getting clobbered as well: Weatherford [WFT  Loading...      ()   ]down 11 percent, National Oilwell Varco [NOV  Loading...      ()   ]down 15 percent, Noble [NE  Loading...      ()   ]down 9 percent, Tidewater [TDW  Loading...      ()   ]down 8 percent.

Folks, that seems like a lot more than demand destruction to me.

In the middle of this, oil services giant Schlumberger said that it expects North American natural gas drilling to stay strong through 2009. The reaction? Stock goes from $86 to $87, still down 3 percent. Strange.

_____________________________
New!

- Track The Dow 30 Now

_______________________________________
CNBC's Names in the News:

Apple [AAPL  Loading...      ()   ]

Home Depot [HDP  Loading...      ()   ]

_______________________________________


LATEST FROM TRADER TALK

Questions?  Comments? 

© 2008 CNBC, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Permalink: /id/26530361