More Videos
- 3D's Tipping Point and Your Living Room
- Silicon Valley and Hollywood Now Fast Friends
- HP Comes in As Expected; Is It Time to Buy?
- Apple Comes to AT&T's Rescue
- My Top 10 Tech Toys for the Holidays
- iPhone a Better Gaming Platform Than Android?
- Dell Has Some Explaining to Do
- Dell May Start to Show Some Promise
- Has Twitter's Finest Hours (Seconds) Come and Gone?
- Intel's Andy Bryant Offers An Explanation
MOST SHARED
- The 'Real' Jobless Rate: 17.5% Of Workers Are Unemployed
- GM's Agreement to Sell Saab To Swedish Firm Falls Apart
- CNBC Anchor Takes a Sabbatical
- Privately Held Facebook Creates Dual-Class Stock
- Buyers Look For Bargains At Luxury Condo Auction
- NBA D-League On The Rise
- Amended Berkshire Hathaway Filing Indicates No Secret Stock Stakes at End of Q3
- Just In Time for Holidays: More Gloom and Doom on Economy
- Behind The Scenes With Warren Buffett
- On Twitter, Beware False Prophets
- S&P to Hit 1,200 by Year-End: Chief Investor
- Amended Berkshire Hathaway Filing Indicates No Secret Stock Stakes at End of Q3
- Facebook's Biggest-Ever Holiday Shopping Season
- Facebook's New Dual Class Structure - Slow Steps to an IPO
- 5 Big Bank Stocks Investors Should Consider: Strategists
- Gambling Drunk, Texting to Live And America's On Sale - Your Emails
- Nov. 24: Unusual Volume Leaders
- NBA D-League On The Rise
- 3D's Tipping Point and Your Living Room
- Citi Mortgage Reveals Something the US Treasury Won't
- Fed Sanguine About US Recovery, Worried on Jobs
- Amended Berkshire Filing Reveals No 'Secret' Holdings
- In Time for Holidays: More Gloom and Doom on Economy
- Turkey Day 101: How Well Do You Know Your Bird?
- Privately Held Facebook Creates Dual-Class Stock
- Holiday Guide to This Season's Smartphones
- Six Ways to Boost Your Income in a Big Way
- Gambling Drunk, Eggos on eBay & More: Your Emails
RSS FEED
Tech Check
Text Size 
 |
Oliver P. Quillia for cnbc.com Morgan Stanley |
While so many other firm's have been lowering price targets on Apple [AAPL
Loading...
()
] for weeks, Morgan Stanley analyst Katie Huberty holds the distinction of being the first to take an Apple target below $100. Her $95 target is the first double-digit one on the Street, and it comes at a time when Apple investors finally began to settle into a nice, stable, though small momentum to the upside.
Timing is everything. What I can't understand is why this analyst still carries the influence she does. I don't know Katie Huberty but I do follow her work. Closely. So do many of you. Andy Zaky has written extensively about Huberty's track record, missing revenue estimates by almost $1 billion and EPS by 6 cents. Those numbers could almost be forgiven because of the meaningless guidance Apple normally provides. Her estimates on individual business units, however, have been way, way off. She was 700,000 units below iPhone's performance, 2 million units light on her iPod estimate and 200,000 units under Apple's Mac number.
This has been detailed extensively. We all know these numbers and her track record. And yet as soon as she publishes, as is the case today, Apple shares nosedive. Nevermind the news, the trends, the fundamentals, research elsewhere. A lower target is a lower target, apparently, no matter where it comes from.
Huberty has turned lowering Apple targets into a bloodsport. She took her target down twice in a matter of days back in September. Today, her reasoning for a lower target comes because of worries about iPhone sales and a nervous consumer. Tell me something I don't know.
Zaky wrote me today, saying, "Apple, for the first time since pre- Lehman Bros. collapse, tested, and broke through the 50-day moving average. Apple also broke through resistance at $100 a share. If anyone wanted to keep Apple's stock price down, today would be the day to downgrade Apple's stock price. Not saying that Kathryn Huberty has any such motivation, but her timing is unusually coincidental."
Conspiracy theorists unite? Maybe, but it does seem weird, especially as Huberty's note comes amid so many other analysts tracking iPhone sales momentum, including FBR out with a report this morning which concludes an iPhone slowdown, but not nearly as bad as some people thought. And there's also that pending deal with Wal-Mart [WMT
Loading...
()
] .
Don't get me wrong: I'm not saying all is perfectly rosey. Geez, even Gene Munster lowered his Apple target. Sales are indeed slowing. But we know that. Have known that. Huberty might have reason to be at a Street low with her new target this morning. Yet her reasons are the same ones echoed by everyone else before her and her target is way below everyone else. Just like her iPhone, iPod and Mac unit sales figures. Which is something you might want to consider when trying to determine whether $95 is realistic. Or whether Huberty, like Apple sometimes does, is sandbagging Apple investors. Again.
Questions? Comments?
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes