The Faber Report
- Paulson Funds Report Q3 Performance
- Asking the Wrong Vivendi Question
- Don’t Jump on the Mead Johnson Rumor
- Sprint Back in Takeover Spotlight, But Should It Be?
- Atticus Founder Walks Away, Leaving High Water Mark Behind
- AIG Rallies for Now, but Future Remains Unclear
- AIG’S Big Move
- CIT Looks Set to File for Bankruptcy
- SEC Finally Settles Its 'Koz'
- Beware GM Equity
MOST SHARED
- The 'Real' Jobless Rate: 17.5% Of Workers Are Unemployed
- Wednesday's Economic News Crunch Could Tilt Markets
- The Social Media Gaming Threat
- NBA D-League On The Rise
- Obama Reiterates Commitment to Boost US-India Ties
- Australia Wheat Exporters Face Challenges: GrainCorp
- Stifling Anger at Work Can Kill, Survey Finds
- Japan Export Rebound Eases Fear of New Recession
- China Shipbuilding to Launch $937 Million China IPO
- Rethinking Work
- Citi Mortgage Reveals What Treasury Won't
- S&P to Hit 1,200 by Year-End: Chief Investor
- Amended Berkshire Hathaway Filing Indicates No Secret Stock Stakes at End of Q3
- Facebook's Biggest-Ever Holiday Shopping Season
- Facebook's New Dual Class Structure - Slow Steps to an IPO
- 5 Big Bank Stocks Investors Should Consider: Strategists
- Gambling Drunk, Texting to Live And America's On Sale - Your Emails
- Nov. 24: Unusual Volume Leaders
- NBA D-League On The Rise
- AIG Board OKs CEO Pay; Benmosche Agrees to Stay
- Obama Reiterates Commitment to Boost US-India Ties
- FDIC's Bair Cautions on Risks in Bank Break-Up Plan
- Wednesday's Economic News Crunch Could Tilt Markets
- Call Me Crazy: Confessions of a Black Friday Shopper
- 'Very Blah' Christmas Is Coming for UK Retailers
- US Firms Hit by Payroll Taxes at Exactly the Wrong Time
- Citi Mortgage Reveals Something the US Treasury Won't
- Fed Sanguine About US Recovery, Worried on Jobs
RSS FEED
Text Size 
CNBC Anchor and Reporter
 |
Jae C. Hong / AP |
]. Ackman is seeking representation on Target’s board of directors.
Today, two firms that make their money by advising shareholders who they support in such battles came out with their recommendations.
These opinions, particularly the ones from the firm Riskmetrics, can play an important role in determining who will emerge victorious in such proxy fights.
While I dutifully report their conclusions, my own conclusion after days like today is that these firms should not exist in the first place.
Why should any institution outsource the decision of whom to vote for in a particular proxy fight to an outside firm?
To be fair, most institutional investors do not rely on proxy advisory firms in order to figure out whom they will support. But quite a few do.
Index funds are the obvious audience for services such as these, but I wonder how difficult it would be for these firms as well as many others to use their own discretion in reviewing the merits of a particular proxy fight.
Can it really be that hard or time consuming to be responsible for helping to determine the future of a company of which you own a stake?
I think not.
_____________________________
_____________________________
Questions? Comments? Write to .
- Remember when auto shows were major events where new models could generate buzz?
- CNBC’s Mike Huckman visits a cutting-edge plant to see how the flu vaccine of the future is being made.
- People who bottle up their anger at work are up to five times more likely to suffer a heart attack, a study found.
- Playboy will outsource its publishing operations in a bid to become profitable again.
- A new McDonald's in Manhattan is the nation's first to sport a sleek, chic interior imported from stores in London and Paris.
- For nearly three decades, these on-call experts have been dishing advice on how to – and not to – cook turkey.
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes