Bash or Bolster? Bank Bosses on Obama Blueprint

President Obama's proposed financial reform has sparked a debate among lawmakers and members of the financial sector. Some argue that the plan's creation of a separate consumer protection agency will cause unnecessary confusion, while others say it will give the Federal Reserve too much power. CNBC talked to the experts for their opinion on the proposal.

Banker in the Middle

"The problem with creating an entirely separate consumer examination force is that their objectives are different from the safety and soundness force, and they clash, and they’re going to catch the banker in the middle.”

Camden Fine, president and CEO of the Independent Community Bankers of America

A Collaborative Effort

"I commend the President for getting personally involved in this and taking leadership and putting his own considerable influence behind the efforts ... We're still analyzing the white paper and want to work with the administration and Congress constructively on this."

Sheila Bair, FDIC chairman

'Fannie and Freddie Redux'

"If the Federal Reserve is responsible for institutions it deems to be systemically critical, systemically important, then the marketplace is going to adjust to that. Their stocks are going to be more dear, lenders will lend to them on more favored rates ... It's Fannie and Freddie redux."

Emil Henry, former treasury assistant secretary

Consumer Examination Force Could be 'Tricky'

"There's no really separating the good of the consumer ... from the quality of the loan as some people would suggest. I think it's very important if you're going to have good credit that it be properly constructed, that the consumer understand the credit, be able to repay it, so there isn't that conflict that some people suggest ... Layering another oversight body on that could be tricky."

Tom Hoenig, president and CEO of Kansas City Fed

Reform Will Hit Small Banks Hard

"We have the same quantity of regulation, but we're much smaller companies, and therefore it costs us a great deal more and it puts us under a great deal more pressure."

Mike Menzies, president and CEO of Easton Bank and Trust

An 'Unnecessary Confusion'

"As a banker, we want clarity ... We want to make sure that we know who's regulating us and what the rules are. The consumer protection agency sounds a bit confusing ... I don't really mind the idea of consumer protection, I think it makes sense and it's well timed, I just think that the agency itself might be a little problematic.

Richard Davis, US Bancorp CEO

Contact U.S. News


    Get the best of CNBC in your inbox

    Please choose a subscription

    Please enter a valid email address
    To learn more about how we use your information,
    please read our Privacy Policy.

Don't Miss

  • Former Kleiner partner Ellen Pao arrives at San Francisco Superior Court, March 24, 2015.

    Ellen Pao’s lawsuit against her former employer, Silicon Valley VC firm Kleiner Perkins, is frivolous—and a setback for women, says Carol Roth.

  • A pedestrian walks by a Lululemon retail store on September 12, 2014 in San Francisco, California

    It looks like Lululemon has learned a lesson from its past controversies, and is working to develop merchandise to fit a fuller-figured customer.

  • Beer Label Madness 2015 - South - Yule Shoot Your Eye Out

    As voting gets underway in Round Two of CNBC's most loved beer label contest, here's a look at those that prevailed in Round One.

U.S. Video