Skip navigation


Current DateTime: 02:07:23 09 Feb 2012
LinksList Documentid: 23452764
Expiration DateTime: 2/9/2012 2:09:24 AM

Current DateTime: 02:07:25 09 Feb 2012
LinksList Documentid: 23452000
Expiration DateTime: 2/9/2012 2:09:40 AM

Current DateTime: 02:07:25 09 Feb 2012
LinksList Documentid: 24355697

MOST SHARED


Current DateTime: 02:07:25 09 Feb 2012
LinksList Documentid: 31330905
Expiration DateTime: 2/9/2012 2:09:45 AM

MOST POPULAR


Current DateTime: 02:07:27 09 Feb 2012
LinksList Documentid: 35819650
    • Super Bowl, Super Bucks

        Whether it's the Patriots or Giants who actually win the game, the business of the Super Bowl is a touchdown either way.

HOT ON FACEBOOK

Opinion: Selling Organs for Cash Should be Option

By: Michelle Caruso-Cabrera, CNBC Senior International Correspondent | 22 Jun 2009 | 12:05 PM ET
Text Size

When it comes to Apple [AAPL  Loading...      ()   ] and Steve Jobs, all the focus today will be on whether the company should have revealed the state of Jobs' health. That is unfortunate. This story should serve as another lesson in the evils of government intervention.

What do we know about organs that people need in order to survive? There aren’t enough of them. Want more? Pay for them. Give people a financial incentive to give up their liver when they die. Supply will sky rocket.

Are you aghast? I’m going to infuriate you even more with this one: Let living people sell a kidney.  

One argument against paying the deceased's family for organs is the fear that those relatives will be more likely to let the donor die at crucial decision making points. Well, under that logic, you’d have to outlaw all inheritances.

Another argument you will hear: If you let people sell a kidney, you are exploiting the poor as they are the only one’s who will be desperate enough to do so.

More on Steve Jobs, Apple:

Yes, the poor will be the suppliers, but I think it is paternalistic to tell them what they can or cannot do with their bodies. In addition, they could be making a very rationale choice.

Will the money they receive make their family's life far better than? It is easy when you are well off to dictate to the poor the kinds of decisions they should make about their lives. Get off your high horse.

And seriously, do you think the current system doesn’t benefit the rich and well-connected?  The minute you have rationing and government control like we do right now, the system is ripe for those who have money and friends to get moved up the list and game the system.

© 2012 CNBC.com
Tools:
Add This share icon

CNBC HIGHLIGHTS

  • Road Warrior - Taxi Magic App
  • These will help you file expenses, sign documents, process orders, book a cab and more.
  • GOP Candidate Rick Santorum
  • Former US senator Rick Santorum rejuvenated his campaign with a sweep of three nominating contests.
  • Most people could be in business for themselves, says expert Kevin Ready, but not everybody should. Here’s why.
  • Cars at port
  • The increase in hiring for the auto industry in the US shows that America has become a huge auto exporter, says Phil LeBeau.
  • house
  • For those thinking of retiring, one step is to rightsize your house now, says our guest blogger.
  • Bacon Milkshake
  • Jack in the Box is going whole hog with its new menu item. That’s right... it's a bacon milkshake.


Current DateTime: 04:55:06 08 Feb 2012
LinksList Documentid: 29778428

Current DateTime: 04:23:59 08 Feb 2012
LinksList Documentid: 29779196

Current DateTime: 05:02:56 08 Feb 2012
LinksList Documentid: 29779197

Current DateTime: 10:53:22 08 Feb 2012
LinksList Documentid: 29779199
CNBCCNBC
About CNBC  |  Site Map  |  Video Reprints   |  Advertise  |  Help  |  Contact
Privacy Policy  |     |  Terms of Service  |  Independent Programming Report
  Data is a real-time snapshot  *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes
Global Business and Financial News, Stock Quotes, and Market Data and Analysis

© 2012 CNBC LLC.  All Rights Reserved.
A Division of NBCUniversal
Thomson ReutersThomson Reuters