Skip navigation
CNBC.comCNBC.com
Boom, Bust & Blame -- The Inside Story of America's Economic CrisisBoom, Bust & Blame: The Inside Story of America's Economic Crisis
By The Numbers
Sometimes numbers tell a more dramatic story than words or pictures. Check out our charts and graphs to see how subprime mortgages, risky securities, relaxed lending standards, poor regulation, and lax oversight, along with greed and ignorance led to a boom, a bust, and lots of shared blame.

1. Greenspan's Cheap Money

The financial collapse of 2008 has been described as an “economic 9/11” for the United States. How ironic, then, that the origin of the collapse can be traced, in part, to the federal government’s response to the 9/11 terrorist attacks themselves.


(1.1)Fed Funds Target Rate
> Back to Greenspan's Cheap Money


(1.2)30-yr Mortgage Rates
> Back to Greenspan's Cheap Money

2. The Great Housing Boom

As the cost of borrowing dropped, so did the cost of the American Dream. Falling mortgage rates fueled a new residential real estate boom across the country. Millions of buyers flooded the market, purchasing condos, townhouses, and single-family homes they previously might not have been able to afford.

(2.1)Home Ownership vs Affordability‘
> Back to the Great Housing Boom


(2.2)Rising Home Values
> Back to the Great Housing Boom


(2.3)Single Family Housing Starts
> Back to the Great Housing Boom


(2.4)Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Exposure to Residential Mortgages
> Back to the Great Housing Boom

3. Subprime Explosion

As home values rose and home ownership increased,  some Americans were left out. But not for long. Before the boom, they didn’t make enough money or their credit score wasn’t high enough to get a mortgage. They didn’t qualify. Lenders wouldn’t loan these potential borrowers money because their risk of defaulting was too high, by most standards. When those standards started to change, an industry near extinction was reborn.

(3.1)Subprime Originations
> Back to Subprime Explosion


(3.2)Growth and Fall of Subprime
> Back to Subprime Explosion


(3.3)Cash-Out Dollars
> Back to Subprime Explosion

4. Inflating The Bubble

The days when a bank issued a mortgage and held onto it for the life of that loan ended long ago. Mortgages had become huge profit-generators for investment banks, which bought the loans from other banks and non-bank lenders, packaged them together, sliced them up, and sold them as securities.  In theory, as long as homeowners paid their mortgages, these securitized loan investments, also known as structured products, were relatively safe.  But, theory and practice were two very different things.


(4.1)Loose Lending Standards > Back to Inflating The Bubble


(4.2)Subprime Balance
> Back to Inflating The Bubble


(4.3)Issuance Volumes
> Back to Inflating The Bubble


(4.4)Ratings Agencies Misleading
> Back to Inflating The Bubble

5. Warning Signs

As the housing bubble inflated, few regulators took notice. If they did, many turned a blind eye. Even Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan acknowledged during a Fed meeting in November 2002 that “our extraordinary housing boom cannot continue indefinitely.” His words turned out to be drastic understatements and they would later come back to haunt him.


(5.1)Fed Funds Rate vs Housing Starts
> Back to Warning Signs


(5.2)Top Subprime Lenders
> Back to Warning Signs

(5.3)Single Family Housing Starts
> Back to Warning Signs



(5.4)Short Seller Profits
> Back to Warning Signs

6. Housing Market Decline

By early 2006, America’s unprecedented real estate explosion was hitting a wall. The boom hadn’t turned to a bust, yet. But the housing market was slowing significantly. The evidence was clear: back-to-back quarterly drops in the median price of a home showed cracks in the armor of a market many experts believed would keep growing indefinitely.


(6.1)Subprime Delinquency Rate
> Back to Housing Market Decline


(6.2)California Home and Condos
> Back to Housing Market Decline


(6.3)Rising Mortgage Payments
> Back to Housing Market Decline



(6.4)U.S. Debt Crises
> Back to Housing Market Decline


(6.5)Consumer Credit Outstanding
> Back to Housing Market Decline



(6.6)Refinancing Boom Hits Wall
> Back to Housing Market Decline

(6.7)Median Home Prices After Crash
> Back to Housing Market Decline

7. Banks Go Into Panic Mode

The ripple effects of the housing slowdown on Main Street were now reaching Wall Street, especially firms that invested heavily in subprime mortgages. The sudden collapse of two Bear Stearns hedge funds in June 2007 triggered the beginning of the panic among institutional investors, including investment banks, hedge funds, and sovereign wealth funds. Their voracious appetites for securitized mortgage products would soon come to an end.


(7.1)Biggest One Day Dow Moves
> Back to Banks Go Into Panic Mode


(7.2)Subprime Ratings
> Back to Banks Go Into Panic Mode

8. Financial Collapse

The uncertainly on Wall Street took a new, more ominous turn, and once again, Bear Stearns is at the center of the storm. It would overwhelm the firm, and during the course of just a few days, one of Wall Street’s most venerable names would be taken over by a rival, despite unprecedented government efforts to prevent the company from failing.

(8.1)JP Morgan vs Bear
> Back to Financial Collapse


(8.2)Bear vs S&P Financials
> Back to Financial Collapse

9. Global Recession

The ripple effects of the subprime securitization scandal continued  simmering through the summer. It would soon boil up to become the greatest financial crisis since the Great Depression, with incredible economic, political, and social ramifications. More well-known firms would go out of business, others would be bought by competitors, or get bailed out by the government. Millions of workers across all industries and sectors would lose their jobs. And the perception of prosperity that many Americans enjoyed for years would become a bitter reality:  we had spent, borrowed, and fooled ourselves into a false sense of security.

(9.1)Control of AIG
> Back to Global Recession

(9.2)Bank Failures Since 2000
> Back to Global Recession

(9.3)Money Maket Yields
> Back to Global Recession


(9.4)Dow & S&P 500 Performance
> Back to Global Recession

10. Massive Government Action

The initial $700 Billion economic stimulus plan authorized by Congress was only the tip of the bailout iceberg. Between October 2008 and June 2009, the U.S. government committed more than $10 Trillion dollars to economic recovery packages. In that nine-month period, the federal government took aggressive, unprecedented action, using new and existing powers to shore up the markets, thaw the credit freeze, and stop the economic free-fall. Recovery from this crisis was still a long way off, but signs of stability started to emerge.

(10.1)Citigroup Stock Performance
> Back to Massive Government Action

(10.2)Government Invests in Financials
> Back to Massive Government Action

(10.3)Signs of Life in Housing
> Back to Massive Government Action


(10.4)Test Results Reveals Stronger and Weaker Banks
> Back to Massive Government Action


(10.5)Bank Failures Since 2000
> Back to Massive Government Action