The Faber Report

Published: Wednesday, 15 Jul 2009 | 9:55 AM ET

Text Size

I’ve noticed today that shares of GM

GMGMQ loading...

Quote  |  Chart  |  News  |  Profile

[GMGMQ  Loading...      ()   ], which have absolutely no value, are trading up 39% to well over $1 a share.

The stock no longer trades on the NYSE, but still trades over the counter.

It is typical to see shares of a bankrupt company continue to trade for some value, despite the highly likely outcome that those shares will have no value.

But, this is truly bizarre because GM has emerged from bankruptcy. These shares should not even exist any longer let alone trade for any value.

It seems likely that some unsophisticated investors, reading the headlines about GM’s emergence from bankruptcy, are buying its stock. The problem is that the old stock has no claim on the “new” GM and no value. It’s also possible that some investors, knowing that other investors would pile in today, were buying shares with the knowledge they can sell them to the clueless people who think they’re getting in on the “new” GM.

It may be a while until we see shares of the new GM.

The company’s CFO told our Phil Lebeau that an IPO could come at the earliest in the second quarter of next year.

We will see when issued market in those shares emerge well before an IPO, but that is also some time from now.

UPDATE: The SEC and FINRA jointly issued this investor alert today …

Investing in a Bankrupt Company: A High Risk Venture

The SEC and FINRA are issuing this Alert because we believe there may be widespread misunderstanding by investors that stock in the “old” General Motors Corporation (now known as Motors Liquidation Company) is related to the “new” General Motors Company (new GM). FINRA halted trading in old GM (which had been using the GMGMQ trading symbol) on July 10, 2009, and has since issued a new ticker symbol for the old GM stock—MTLQQ—to avoid having it confused with the new GM, which currently has no publicly traded securities.

This Alert also reminds investors that holding shares of any company involved in bankruptcy, or buying shares in a bankrupt company in the hope that those shares will surge in value down the road, are highly risky courses of action.

Furthermore, as with the GM situation, companies in bankruptcy are often the subject of rumors in fax or email newsletters, Internet message rooms or on Web sites offering online stock tips. Unfortunately, investors may have received confusing, potentially misleading, information about the old GM. As recently as last Friday (July 10, 2009), newsletters and other promoters have touted the purchase of the stock.

Two Distinct Companies

Motors Liquidation Company and the “new” GM are separate and distinct. As stated on the Web sites of both Motors Liquidation Company and the new GM, the new GM currently has no publicly traded securities, and none of Motors Liquidation Company’s publicly owned stocks or bonds are or will become securities of the new GM. Motors Liquidation Company is currently winding its way through bankruptcy court—and there is a real possibility that stock holders will receive nothing from these proceedings. While the common stock of Motors Liquidation has not been cancelled, investors should not interpret that as indicating that the shares have any value.

"Q" is for Caution

Investors are often confused by the fact that, despite the likelihood that the common stock of a bankrupt company will be cancelled, the company's securities may continue to trade after the company has filed for bankruptcy protection and before it emerges as a newly reorganized company. This confusion may be aggravated by the lengthy bankruptcy process—which may take months, if not years. Such securities typically trade on either the OTCBB or the Pink Sheets and the stock symbol will have a fifth letter "Q" at the end to denote the company’s bankrupt status.

Risks of Trading in Securities of Bankrupt Companies

When a company files for reorganization under the federal bankruptcy laws, investors are often tempted to buy or hold the company’s common stock in anticipation that the company that emerges from bankruptcy will be profitable. The reality is, however, that when companies emerge from bankruptcy, the common stock of the “old” company is usually worthless. In most instances, the company's plan of reorganization will cancel the existing equity shares.

In general, while a typical bankruptcy reorganization plan allows the “new” company to distribute new shares under a new trading symbol, holders of the common stock of the “old” company generally do not receive any of these shares. A company must pay off existing debt before it emerges from bankruptcy—and creditors, including bondholders, usually receive shares in the new company as partial payment. This leaves little or nothing of value for the common stockholders of the “old” company. This may seem unfair, but it reflects the established priority scheme of bankruptcy and the fact that, in contrast to bond holders, common stock holders take greater risk, but have the potential for the greater gain. For more information on the corporate bankruptcy process, see the SEC’s brochure entitled Corporate Bankruptcy.

We are concerned that some investors purchase shares of companies in Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the belief that if the company survives, the old common stock will have value—not recognizing that the old common stock is likely to be cancelled, even if the company emerges from bankruptcy. Investors should understand that buying common stock of companies in Chapter 11 bankruptcy is extremely risky and can lead to financial loss.

If you own shares in a company that has, or may be filing, for bankruptcy, or are considering purchasing shares of a bankrupt company, check the company’s Web site for information about the bankruptcy. Also check the company’s SEC filings, available through the SEC’s EDGAR database or on the company’s Web site, and other publicly available information for company statements about its reorganization plan as well as a copy of the reorganization plan itself. For more information on using EDGAR and where to find information on a company’s bankruptcy, seeResearching Public Companies Through EDGAR: A Guide for Investors.

CNBC.com Special Report: The Fall Of GM

_____________________________

• The Dow 30 in Real Time
• The CNBC Stock Blog

_____________________________

Questions?  Comments?  Write to

Print

Email

Text Size