Trader Talk
- Hostage to Headlines
- Facebook Analyst Reports All Over the Map
- More Fallout From the Facebook Fiasco
- Facebook and Morgan Stanley's 99 Problems
- Lousy Economic Numbers, but Stocks Hold Up
- Eurobond Talk: Good News and Bad News
- Hopes Fading for Big Announcement From EU Leaders
- European 'Crisis Tennis' Again
- Facebook IPO 'Conspiracy' Theories Abound
- OK, Facebook Is Embarrassing
TRADER TALK RSS FEED
MOST SHARED
- Labor Board Member Resigns Over Leak to GOP Allies
- JPMorgan Beefs Up China Unit With $400-Million Injection
- Despite Graft Probe, Sun Hung Kai Is a Buy on Quality Assets: Pros
- Bankia Shares Open 26.75% Down After Bailout Request
- Australia's Hastie Collapses as Building Sector Struggles
- European Shares, Euro Gain as Greek Fears Ease
- Draft EU Report Attacks Italy on Economy
- Beijing Faces Brussels Action on Telecoms Aid
- Japan's Nomura Linked to Another Insider Trading Case
- Buy Asian Stocks Now as Market Panics Over Europe: Analyst
- A New Look at the ‘New Poor’
- Six Pack: Beer Buzz of the Week
- Greek Exit Could Trigger 50% Fall in Euro Stocks: Analyst
- Under Pressure, FHA Skews to Wealthier Home Buyers
- Big Stock Upside for Hudson City Deal: Analyst
- 5 High-Yield Stocks Ready to Boost Dividends
- Yoshikami: Four Things You Need to Know About Gold Now
- Steinbock: The Euro Zone Endgame Begins
- Option Bulls Take Another Shot on Idenix
- Leading Broker to Leave Greece Stock Market
- Euro Bond Wins Supporters, but Details Remain Vague
- German, UK Bond Yields Will Go Even Lower
- Southern Europeans Wire Cash to Safer North
- Labor Board Member Resigns Over Leak to GOP Allies
- JPMorgan Beefs Up China Unit With $400-Million Injection
- Euro Rallies as Greece's Pro-Bailout Parties Gain Favor
- Olive Oil Price Dip Adds to European Woes
- Buy Asian Stocks as Market Panics Over Europe: Expert
The Death of Commodity ETFs and ETNs?
Text Size 
Reporter
Several commodity ETFs and ETNs have announced that they are not issuing new shares, which means the only shares that will exist are the ones that exist now.
As a result, several funds are now trading at a premium to their underlying indexes. How did this happen, and when did ETFs and ETNs become closed end funds?
Blame it on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), which announced they were conducting investigations into speculation in the commodities market.
"Speculators" are anybody who isn't using commodities futures to hedge--this would be anyone who was not an oil company, or actively involved in production of commodities.
That leaves hedge funds, and other investors...including commodity ETFs and ETNs.
As a result, several companies behind commodity ETFs and ETNs have gotten spooked.
Look what has happened to the United States Natural Gas Fund [UNG
Loading...
()
]. This owns the front-month natural gas contract. Since they announced last week that they would not be issuing new shares, even after the SEC gave them approval to do so, the fund has been trading at a premium to the underlying natural gas contract.
This is like a closed end fund now (which only issues a set number of shares, and can trade at premiums or discounts to their underlying value), and adds significant additional trading risk.
Why? Because you're not just buying natural gas anymore, you're buying natural gas PLUS the scarcity value of the natural gas fund.
This is a good example of the Law of Unintended Consequences. We have a problem: We think there are Dark, Mysterious Forces secretly controlling the universe (and the commodities markets), and these must be investigated. But in the process of doing that, perfectly good products get blown out.
The CFTC needs to clear this up. They need to either issue clear rules, or make it clear that ETFs and ETNs are not part of this...investigation.
I will be discussing this with two ETF experts on Closing Bell today at 3 PM ET.
Halting Share Issuance:
- U.S. Natural Gas Fund [UNG
Loading...
()
]
- PowerShares DB Crude Oil Double Long ETN [DXO
Loading...
()
]
- iPath DJ-AIG Natural Gas ETN [GAZ
Loading...
()
]
_____________________________
_____________________________
Questions? Comments?
- The Nasdaq has suffered the most from the EU crisis showing there's risk in the usual tech stocks.
- Targeting more Millennials is just one of the items brewing for consumers in the world of spirits.
- It seems many people may need a reminder of how NOT to act on a plane. Here are a few tips.
- Here are some very unusual roadside stops along American highways that might peek your interest.
- How three generations of Americans are dealing with the finances of retirement.
- Hostage to Headlines
- Facebook Analyst Reports All Over the Map
- More Fallout From the Facebook Fiasco
- Facebook and Morgan Stanley's 99 Problems
- Lousy Economic Numbers, but Stocks Hold Up
- Eurobond Talk: Good News and Bad News
- Hopes Fading for Big Announcement From EU Leaders
- European 'Crisis Tennis' Again
- Facebook IPO 'Conspiracy' Theories Abound
- OK, Facebook Is Embarrassing
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes
