'Carelessness Towards the Law' at Ratings Agencies

Friday, 2 Oct 2009 | 8:22 AM ET

Reform of rating agencies is badly needed as there is a culture of carelessness towards the law which needs challenging, Eric Kolchinsky, a former analyst at Moody's who has accused the agency of issuing inflated ratings, told CNBC Friday.

"I don't want to overstate this but years and decades of saying we have this first amendment protection has created carelessness towards the law. I think that's sort of a cultural problem in the rating agencies," Kolchinsky, who was suspended by the agency, said.

Kolchinsky has accused Moody's Investor Service of issuing a high rating to a complicated debt security in January, in spite of it being aware it was planning to downgrade assets backing the securities.

Moody's Whistleblower Speaks
Insight on a 14-page memo blasting Moody's for practices he says broke the law, with Eric Kolchinsky, former Moody's Investors Service managing director and CNBC's Carl Quintanilla.

(See the accompanying video for the complete interview.)

"They knew the ratings were wrong and still, with that knowledge, they rated it as high rate," he told "Squawk Box."

He sent a detailed report of his findings to Congress.

"Hopefully you'll have a real rating agencies reform, capital markets reform, but I don't know," Kolchinsky said.

Moody's said they investigated all Kolchinsky's claims and found they were unsupported.

"Moody's is confident in the integrity of its people and its processes," the agency said in a statement. Kolchinsky is currently unemployed.

"Right now I'm looking for work, like a lot of other people," he told CNBC.

  Price   Change %Change


  • Discussing loan growth in financials and the drag of litigation on Bank of America's earnings, with Gerard Cassidy, RBC Capital Markets lead banking analyst.

  • Ken Moelis, Moelis & Company founder and CEO, discusses the public debut of his company on the NYSE and explains his boutique investment banking model. "Clients will want the flexibility of an independent, unconflicted advisor," Moelis says.

  • Discussing how to buy in volatile market conditions and the investment banking market, David Katz, Matrix Asset Advisors CIO, and Charles Bobrinskoy, Ariel Investments vice chairman & portfolio manager.