- Farrell: What's Different On This Black Friday
- Crescenzi: Claims Level Suggests End to Job Losses
- Schork Oil Outlook: Gas Bulls Pinning Hopes on Mother Nature
- Busch: The Debt-Interest Rate Paradox
- Busch: Markets Smell a Country Rat
- Schork Oil Outlook: Mission Impossible For The Bears?
- Losey: Asset Allocation At Retirement
- Farrell: Obama Hectored, Ignored and Restricted?
- Don't Dwell on Investment Mistakes; Move on, Like Buffett
- Hirschhorn: Greed...or Fear
MOST SHARED
- 8 Retailers that Gain During the Holidays
- Dubai Fallout Is a Correction, Not Another Crisis: El-Erian
- Finding the Holiday's Best Buys
- Banks Play Down Dubai Exposure, Investors Still Wary
- Dubai Spooks Investors But May Bring Buying Opportunity
- San Miguel Sells $1.36 Billion Stake to Ally
- Charts: Dollar Could Fall to 80 Yen
- Is Super Bowl Halftime Act Too Old?
- ING Prices Share Issue at Hefty Discount
- Obama's Emission Reduction Pledge Paints Future for Autos
- Is Super Bowl Halftime Act Too Old?
- Surprising Options Trades in TiVo Shares
- EA Sports Hopes to Pump Up Sales Through Pop-Up Locations
- 8 Retailers that Gain During the Holidays
- Farrell: What's Different On This Black Friday
- 10 Dividend Picks For Your Portfolio: Chief Investors
- 4 Thanksgiving Week Buys For Your Portfolio: Market Pros
- There's a 'Great Chance' For a Double-Dip Recession: Strategist
- Dubai Fallout Is a Correction, Not Another Crisis: El-Erian
- Dubai's Debt Woes Signal New Era for Creditors
- Banks With The Biggest Exposure to The UAE
- The World's Biggest Debtor Nations
- Commodities Hammered as Investors Flee to US Dollars
- Five Tips for Buying a Foreclosed Home
- Get Paid Six Figures to Wear a T-Shirt?
- Shoppers Hit Black Friday Sales; Budgets Pared
- Slideshow: Fantasy Christmas Gifts 2009
RSS FEED
CNBC Guest Blog
Text Size 
William Dunkelberg
Economic Strategist,
Boenning & Scattergood
Michigan’s governor, appearing on Fox News Sunday (10/11), said that we need the public sector to pick up more of the health care bill so that the private sector can be more competitive.
It is this kind of flawed economic thinking that gets us into so much trouble.
Does the governor think that the public sector gets its funding from thin air, or that doctors work for nothing? Doesn’t she get it?
The private sector pays for the entire health care bill in every country under every scheme. The government does not produce stuff - the private sector does, and earns the income that pays for everything the government promises. I can pay for my health care directly, or I can pay taxes to support Medicare which pays for health care with a lot of administrative costs.
Firms don't have to provide insurance and don't have to keep up with rising costs. It's not law (yet). It is part of total compensation which includes cash, taxes and benefits. In most of the economy, this "pay package" is negotiable. Not so with union contracts however.
 |
The governor complained that health care costs are a large part of the cost of making a U.S. car, making them less competitive.
Well, providing health insurance is not mandated (yet, anyway), and is a result of heavy-handed union activity over the past decades aided by government’s foot on the neck of the industry to avoid strikes. Union power is simply a way to tax non-union workers to the benefit of union workers by forcing companies to pay above market wages and benefits and over-charge for the union made products. This destroyed our basic steel industry and our domestic auto industry in spite of government attempts to use protectionism to shield this bad behavior.
A decade ago I and other economists predicted the demise of these companies as a result.
The only sector of the economy where unions thrive is the public sector which faces no competition and has no bottom line. Garbage collector strikes are always settled so that voters do not get too unhappy and the cost is passed on in higher taxes. Private sector firms do not have that luxury, they face “re-election” daily in a competitive market and must be efficient or “lose the election” as our steel and auto companies have.
Taxpayers spent $50 billion to save union jobs at GM – a continuation of very ill-advised policies that leave our private sector weaker. Continuing to look to government to solve our “problems” and “save us” is a downhill path to lower prosperity.
If consumers want to consume a lot of health care, it is the job of markets to provide it. Spending a lot is not a “crisis”, unless we demand too much because we face the wrong prices (“free” doctor visits for example).
If cars were “free”, we’d take a lot more of those as well.
___________________
William Dunkelberg is an Economic Strategist, Boenning & Scattergood and Chief Economist, National Federation of Independent Business.
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes