- Dubai's Debt Woes Signal New Era for Creditors
- Next Week: Cash In Now Or Wait For A Santa Rally?
- Fed Audit Would Hurt Economic Prospects: Bernanke
- Dubai Stock Selloff May Bring Buying Opportunity
- Longer Lines, Fuller Carts This Black Friday
- Big US Banks May Be Forced to Raise Capital: Bove
- Bank of America Amends Pay for Senior Executives
- Dubai Fallout Is a Correction, Not Another Crisis: El-Erian
- Tiger Woods Out of Hospital After Accident
- U.S. Stocks Fall on Dubai Worries
- Black Friday at Best Buy
- Strategists on Dubai: Avoid 'Rash Moves' Now
- Longer Lines, Fuller Carts This Black Friday
- Dubai Stock Market Fear Has 'Legs': Dennis Gartman
- Obama's Emission Reduction Pledge Paints Future for Autos
- Is Super Bowl Halftime Act Too Old?
- Surprising Options Trades in TiVo Shares
- EA Sports Hopes to Pump Up Sales Through Pop-Up Locations
Text Size 
CNBC.com
Choosing between indexed and managed funds is really no choice at all: Investors who rely solely on one or the other these days are doomed to failure.
 |
iStock photo |
The situation has been a case of pick your poison as index funds are right back where they started after a volatile 10-year journey, and managed funds in risk-adjusted real terms actually have underperformed even that low standard.
So who has been a winner in all this market malaise?
It's been investors who have used smart combinations of both to maximize returns when the market has presented opportunity and protected portfolios when danger has come.
"Investors need to look at this not as a choice of one or the other," says Paul Lebouef, financial consultant for Charles Schwab. "A lot of times a mix of both is perhaps the most prudent choice."
Amid the turbulence of the past years a managed fund historically would be considered the more reliable option. That's because managers have more leeway to hold safe-haven cash and take short positions in a down market than an index fund.
Index funds mimic the performance of a broad range of stocks such as the Dow Jones industrials or transportation averages, the Standard & Poor's 500 or the MSCI Commodity Index and don't have the adaptability to market changes that a managed fund provides.
Yet managed funds have won the battle only 37 percent of the time in the past three years, according to a recent report from Morningstar that emphasizes how not all managed funds are created equal and investors need to shop carefully.
"The fact that the average active fund doesn't beat an index fund doesn't necessarily mean that you shouldn't use active funds. It means you have to set the bar high," says Russ Kinnel, director of fund research at Morningstar. "It's not so much about performance but other fundamentals."
Managed funds actually have measured about even against the indexes over the past five years in total returns, but falter when adjusted for risk. Because of the wild gyrations the market has seen, investors have tended to bail out of managed funds in bad times, thus missing the upside when the market recovers.
"[P]erformance has not been enough to account for the increase in risk taken on compared with the Morningstar indexes," the firm's report said.
Yet the debate over which option is better rages on.
- These four sectors will be the next to lead the market.
- Zhu Zhu Pets are this year's must-have toy, fetching $40 or more on eBay.
- From the why-didn’t-I-think-of-that file, we present Jason Sadler, a man whose job is wearing T-shirts.
- It may be the most unusual guide to business you'll read.
- Shopping for a gadget hound? The choices can be baffling. Here are a few that should be a hit.
- "The Who" will be the halftime act for Super Bowl XLIV on Feb. 7 in Miami. Is the NFL behind the times?
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes