Money & Politics
- Zero China Growth Is ‘Probable’: Gordon Chang
- With Greece Nearing Euro Exit, Is Cash King?
- Euro Zone Battle Hinges On Greece’s Banks: Steil
- Will Congress Forge Budget Deal, Avoid ‘Fiscal Cliff’?
- Bob Lutz: Auto Bailout Was ‘Right Thing to Do’
- Will European Woes Trigger QE3, Death of Euro?
- Battle Over Congressional Budget Heats Up
- Extend the Bush Tax Cuts Now
- Sen. Coburn: There Will Be a Budget Deal
- Paul Ryan Blames Democrats for Debt Woes
SHOW TIMES
Weeknights 7p ET
CNBC Asia:
Saturday 07:00 SIN/HK
RSS FEED
MOST SHARED
- US Law Firm Dewey Files for Chapter 11, Seeks Liquidation
- Europe Markets Seen Edging Higher; Investors Watch Spain
- Emerging Market Stocks to Test Lehman Lows on 'Grexit'
- Funds Cut Exposure to Euro Zone Banks
- Greek Contagion Could Drag Euro Below $1.19: Charts
- Greece Pours $22.6 Billion Into Four Biggest Banks
- European Firms Plan for Greek Unrest and Euro Exit
- Greece to Leave Euro Zone on June 18: Wealth Manager
- Charting Asia | Euro-Dollar Weekly
- Buy Asian Stocks Now as Market Panics Over Europe: Analyst
CONTACT US
We want to hear from you!
E-mail:
Keynesian Spending has Zilch Effect on Recovery
CNBC Anchor
![]() |
CNBC.com |
The Obama administration continues to argue that its massive federal-spending campaign is essential to economic recovery.
Yet the latest GDP report from the U.S. Department of Commerce shows that the 3.2 percent first-quarter economic growth rate got no help from government spending.
In fact, combined federal, state, and local spending actually fell 1.8 percent. What’s more, over the last three quarters of a mild V-shaped recovery, with an average quarterly rebound of 3.7 percent, government spending actually exerted a small net drag (-0.03%) on growth.
![]() |
I guess it’s time to ask our Keynesian friends in and out of government what exactly happened to those vaunted multiplier effects they so loudly proclaimed. So far, there is zilch effect.
Turns out that all those entitlement transfers of income borrowed and taxed from Peter to pay Paul have made no direct contribution to the nation’s production of goods and services. This, however, comes after $318 billion of spending through April 23, according to the web site recovery.org.
Pretty expensive fiscal habit, wouldn’t you say? But for what?
And who can blame taxpayers for saying, “Show me the money that was supposed to generate growth.” In the winter quarter, consumer spending increased 3.6 percent and business equipment investment rose 13.4 percent, all while inventories were rebuilt by $31 billion. But the G in the GDP equation C+I+G+(X-M) actually dropped. (That is, consumption + investment + government spending + the net exports/imports trade.)
That’s right, dropped.
That failed G for federal, state, and local spending may cost untold trillions of dollars of future tax and debt burdens. Rather than stimulate growth, this will depress it in the years to come — unless we do something about it.
How about stopping the madness right now? How about “de-stimulating” the remaining $500 billion of unspent Keynesianism?
And how about some truth-telling about the big pick-up in business profits that is really behind the recovery — profits that have fueled a stock market boom which has created trillions of dollars of new wealth through capital gains that are being spent and invested in the private sector?
The only temporarily effective government-stimulus effect is coming from the Fed’s free-money, zero-interest-rate policy. And here, too, is stubbornness. For the economic emergency has long passed; the recession ended in last year’s second quarter. Yet the Fed — now controlled by Obama doves — stubbornly persists in maintaining an emergency pump-priming policy that surely will drive up inflation in the years ahead.
More on CNBC.com including:
- US Factory Orders Post Surprising Jump in March
- Slideshow: The Worst 2011 State Budget Gaps
- CNBC Guest Blog - The State of Business Today
- Critical elections are scheduled for Greece in June. Here are some of the players and their roles.
- Our financial system is still not designed to meet the needs of poor families, says this author.
- Statistics show there aren’t many women billionaires compared to their male counterparts. Why?
- Click to see various forms of funding and what entrepreneurs have used to build successful companies.
- Here are some of the most expensive hotels in the world to book. And we mean expen$$ive.
- Always drink responsibly and when you do, try one of these more unusual and tasty drinks. Cheers!











