- Greece Pours $22.6 Billion Into Its Four Biggest Banks
- US Markets Will Be Watching Europe—And Jobs Report
- China's Economic Rebalancing Only Geographical
- Spain's Debt Costs Near Danger Level: Is Bailout Next?
- India's Tumbling Rupee Roils Convertible Bond Market
- Samsung Galaxy S3 Gets Head Start on iPhone
- Greek Contagion Could Drag Euro Below $1.19: Charts
- Japan's Marubeni Nears $5 Billion-Plus Gavilon Deal
- European Companies Plan for Greek Unrest and Euro Exit
- A New Look at the ‘New Poor’
- Six Pack: Beer Buzz of the Week
- Greek Exit Could Trigger 50% Fall in Euro Stocks: Analyst
- Under Pressure, FHA Skews to Wealthier Home Buyers
- Big Stock Upside for Hudson City Deal: Analyst
- 5 High-Yield Stocks Ready to Boost Dividends
- Yoshikami: Four Things You Need to Know About Gold Now
- Steinbock: The Euro Zone Endgame Begins
- Option Bulls Take Another Shot on Idenix
MOST SHARED
- China Rebalances Economy by Shifting Focus Inland
- China Bank Loans Pick Up After Infrastructure Push
- Greece to Leave Euro Zone on June 18: Wealth Manager
- Samsung Galaxy S3 Gets Head Start on iPhone
- Panasonic to Slash Up to 4,000 Jobs; Shares Rise
- Spain's Borrowing Costs Near Danger Level: Bailout Next?
- Greece Pours $22.6 Billion Into Four Biggest Banks
- Crude Prices Stay Firm as US Markets Reopen
- PTT Looks to Tap East African Gas via Cove Energy Bid
- European Firms Plan for Greek Unrest and Euro Exit
MOST POPULAR
HOT ON FACEBOOK
Settlement Is Win for Goldman Despite Record Fine
Text Size 
Senior Editor, CNBC.com
Goldman Sachs scored a major victory in its legal battle with the Securities and Exchange Commission today, despite agreeing to pay a record-setting fine of $550 million.
 |
Getty Images |
] admitted to omitting important information from the marketing materials for the Abacus subprime mortgage derivative products it sold in 2007. But that settlement is far smaller than the $1 billion many expected.
More importantly, Goldman avoided the fraud allegations it feared the most. The one misdeed it to which it confessed—omitting the role of hedge fund manager John Paulson in selecting the securities that went into the synthetic collateralized debt obligation at the heart of the case—is the least damaging in terms of Goldman’s reputation and future legal liability.
In its original complaint, the SEC had accused Goldman of violating Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act and Section 17(a) of the Securities Act. Both are anti-fraud provisions. Like most anti-fraud statutes, Section 10(b) requires the government to prove a fraudulent intent. The first subsection of Section 17(a) also requires proof of fraudulent intent.
But the second and third subsections of 17(a) do not require any proof of intent to defraud.
This makes accusations based on the second and third subsections much easier to prove—and perhaps easier for Goldman to stomach.
In fact, subsection 17(a)(2) does not even employ any form of the word “fraud” or “deceit.” It makes the sale of a security or a derivative unlawful if a material omission renders the sale merely “misleading.” That seems to be what Goldman has admitted to doing in the settlement.
All references to violations of Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act were dropped.
Sources have told CNBC that this allegation of misleading by omission was far more palatable to the Goldman because it does not explicitly implicate Goldman in fraud.
Importantly, most federal courts hold that violations of Section 17(a) of the Securities Act do not give rise to private actions by outside investors.
This means that paying a fine and making this omission will not necessarily give ammunition to plaintiff’s lawyers who are suing Goldman in separate lawsuits.
Although you will never hear them admit it, somewhere Goldman’s lawyers and executives are probably popping the cork on a bottle of bubbly.
This settlement was a win for them.
- Critical elections are scheduled for Greece in June. Here are some of the players and their roles.
- Our financial system is still not designed to meet the needs of poor families, says this author.
- Statistics show there aren’t many women billionaires compared to their male counterparts. Why?
- Click to see various forms of funding and what entrepreneurs have used to build successful companies.
- Here are some of the most expensive hotels in the world to book. And we mean expen$$ive.
- Always drink responsibly and when you do, try one of these more unusual and tasty drinks. Cheers!
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes
