Man Vs. Machine: How the Crash of '87 Gave Birth To High-Frequency Trading
Aiutomation grew out of 1987 market crash
Computer systems linked trading at multiple points.
Computer systems linked to become platforms, ECNs.
The origins of today’s futuristic computer-driven market trace back to a single day of disaster: Black Monday.
On October 19, 1987, the Dow Jones Industrial Average cratered by 23 percent, its biggest one-day decline ever. Stocks were plunging so quickly that Nasdaqmarket makers—the middlemen who grease the markets’ wheels—stopped picking up the phone. Retail investors who wanted to salvage their portfolios were left out in the cold.
In response, Nasdaq tweaked an existing system that would automatically give retail investors preference in the trading queue. It made it mandatory for market makers to instantly execute trades of 1,000 shares or less by retail investors in its Small Order Execution System, or SOES. Market makers and institutional investors, who usually traded in much bigger chunks of stock, had to wait in line behind the SOES traders.
A small coterie of savvy investors smelled an opportunity. Since the SOES trades were automated, meaning they received almost instant execution, and were given priority ahead of the rest of the market, a fast-moving trader could move in and out of stocks using SOES at a far-more rapid clip than large investors, generating big profits.
New Faces, New Players
Perhaps the most famous “SOES bandit,” as these traders came to be known, was Harvey Houtkin, who ran a tiny investing outfit called All-Tech Direct. In the 1990s, Houtkin started to spread the gospel of SOES trading around the country, conducting clinics for would-be bandits.
One person who gravitated to SOES trading was Gerald Putnam, a businessman who owned a small brokerage firm called Terra Nova Trading. In 1996, Putnam teamed up with several partners to launch a SOES trading room in downtown Chicago. Like Houtkin, he started opening up SOES trading rooms around the country. In order to save money on the expensive Nasdaq terminals required to process SOES trades, orders executed by these satellite branches were routed via the Internet to his central station in Chicago.
This gave Putnam an idea: If he could start matching orders of their traders internally they could create an electronic communications network, or ECN, a relatively new marketplace that had been springing up in the 1990s at trading became more computerized.
And there was one specific ECN whose technology Putnam admired: The Island.
The Island was also the offshoot of SOES traders. A New York branch of Datek Securities, a fast-growing firm that catered to day traders, had taken SOES trading to a new level, executing trades at unheard-of speeds. Behind the advance were two young whizzes who would go on to revolutionize markets forever: Jeff Citron and Josh Levine.
Citron and Levine had been hired by Datek trader Sheldon Maschler in the late 1980s when both were in their teens. Maschler had been an associate with Houtkin and was quick to seize the SOES trading opportunity.
Citron came to be known as an ace trader, while Levine was the computer-programming genius who would amp up Datek’s system. In 1990, Maschler moved his operation to a small office on Staten Island. It was there that Citron and Levine created a trading system they dubbed Watcher.
Next Steps, Next Generation
Watcher supercharged SOES trading, giving its users the ability to move in and out of stocks much quicker than most competitors. Along the way, its aggressive tactics drew the ire of regulators. Citron and other Datek executives were fined multiple times for violating securities laws.
As more traders used Watcher, Citron and Levine realized they could often match their trades using an automated computer system, or ECN. Out of that insight, The Island ECN was born.
The Island quickly gained a reputation as having one of the fastest “matching engines”—the computer system that links together buy and sell orders—on Wall Street. As its popularity grew, it started taking market share away from Nasdaq itself.
Putnam had used The Island and saw its potential. But he still had nowhere near the volume of traders that Datek had. So he came up with an idea: Traders could enter trades on his own ECN, and if no matches were found it would scan through the rest of the market for a match.
Thus was born the revolutionary idea of the “smart order router,” a computerized system that constantly monitors the rest of the market for trade matches.
Putnam’s idea, therefore, was to go beyond a single computerized “island” to execute trades to a series of islands linked together electronically. In other words, an “archipelago” of markets. In 1997, he launched the Archipelago ECN.
At the time, Archipelago was just one of several ECNs struggling for market share. But it grew quickly and soon bagged big investments from firms such as Goldman Sachs. The Island was also on the fast track, eating up Nasdaq market share at a rapid clip as more day traders jumped on the bandwagon during the Internet bubble.
Accelerating the growth of the ECNs were new regulations instituted in the aftermath of a scandal that showed that Nasdaq market makers had been manipulating trades. In 1997, the Nasdaq implemented the Order Handling Rules passed by the Securities and Exchange Commission.
These rules mandated that bids and offers for stocks on ECNs would be displayed on terminals right beside those of the Nasdaq market makers. Traders using Archipelago or The Island could have their orders treated just the same as the Nasdaq big shots who’d largely controlled trading.
Old Guard Plays Catch Up
Suddenly, the ECNs were players. As more traders started using their computerized systems, the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq struggled to keep up. In the early 2000s, more and more firms started trading stocks and other securities electronically, often using ECNs. A small but growing collection of high-frequency shops were among the biggest users of the ECNs. TD Ameritradebought Datek in 2002.
Another spur to electronic trading came in 2000 with “decimalization,” the trading of stocks in penny-wide increments rather than fractions of a dollar.
That meant that stocks could trade at many more points than before, a level of complexity easier handled by computers than the human brain.
Decimalization also cut down on the profitability of making markets, since the bid-ask spread narrowed dramatically, causing many established market makers to close shop—opening up the field for the super-efficient, high-speed firms.
The big exchanges could see the writing on the wall. In 2005, Nasdaq purchased Inet, which had been formed by the merger of Island with another large ECN, Instinet. At about the same time, the NYSE purchased Archipelago, which had by then become an exchange known as Arca.
Today, the matching engine at Nasdaq is essentially the same one created in the early 1990s by Josh Levine (which many more bells and whistles, of course). The electronic trading platform at NYSE, now part of NYSE Euronext, is Arca.
Indeed, the computer whizzes have become the dominant players on Wall Street. Earlier this year, Getco, among the largest high-frequency firms, became a designated market maker on the floor of the NYSE, a role formerly held by specialists. This summer, the NYSE opened up a massive computer data center in Mahwah, N.J., to cater to high-speed trading firms.
It’s a market Harvey Houtkin, the original SOES bandit, who died in 2008, would have loved.