Enter multiple symbols separated by commas

Greenberg: Proof — ETFs are Derivatives (Flash Crash Report)

In my recent pieces on whether and ETF can collapse,if there is one thing I heard from the ETF industry and anybody but everybody who disagreed with me it was this (and I’m paraphrasing because this is a g-rated website, John Carney notwithstanding): “Greenberg, you’re wrong: ETFs are not derivatives.”


I now give you this line from the SEC’s Flash Crash report:

“The E-Mini and SPY are the two most active stock index instruments traded in the electronic futures and equity markets. Both are derivative products designed to track stocks in the S&P 500 Index, which in turn represents approximately 75% of the market capitalization of U.S.-listed equities. In order to compare trading and liquidity dynamics in these two products it is important to note their differences so that appropriate side-by-side adjustments can be made.”
That’s a Miracle on 34th Street moment. If the United States Securities and Exchange Commission recognizes ETFs as derivatives, then so do I.

Case closed.

Wall Street

  • Robert Shiller

    Nobel Prize-winning economist Robert Shiller says that his key valuation indicator is flashing warning signs.

  • Lael Brainard

    The Fed is in the early stages of an analysis on changes in bond market liquidity, amid signs that liquidity may be less resilient than in past.

  • Bill Gross

    Janus Capital acquired a majority interest in Kapstream Capital and said Kapstream's Palghat will support Bill Gross as co-portfolio manager of the Janus Global Unconstrained Bond strategy.