BUSINESS NEWS FROM NYTIMES.COM
- Hostage to Headlines
- Facebook Analyst Reports All Over the Map
- More Fallout From the Facebook Fiasco
- Facebook and Morgan Stanley's 99 Problems
- Lousy Economic Numbers, but Stocks Hold Up
- Eurobond Talk: Good News and Bad News
- Hopes Fading for Big Announcement From EU Leaders
- European 'Crisis Tennis' Again
- Facebook IPO 'Conspiracy' Theories Abound
- OK, Facebook Is Embarrassing
- JPMorgan Sells Good Assets to Offset 'London Whale'
- Glitches Halt New Goldman Trade Platform
- Greece Pours $22.6 Billion Into Its Four Biggest Banks
- Funds Cut Exposure to Euro Zone Banks
- US Markets Will Be Watching Europe—And Jobs Report
- As Irish Head to Polls, ‘No’ Voices Get Louder
- Emerging Markets to Test Lehman Lows on 'Grexit'
- Spain's Debt Costs Near Danger Level: Is Bailout Next?
- Samsung Galaxy S3 Gets Head Start on iPhone
MOST SHARED
- U.S. Winds Down Longer Benefits for the Unemployed
- Emerging Market Stocks to Test Lehman Lows on 'Grexit'
- Europe Markets Seen Edging Higher; Investors Watch Spain
- Shell Puts Alberta Oil Sands Project on the Block
- Funds Cut Exposure to Euro Zone Banks
- Greece to Leave Euro Zone on June 18: Wealth Manager
- Egyptians Torch Shafiq HQ as Vote Triggers Violence
- Fire Kills 19, Mostly children, in Upscale Qatar Mall
- Greece Pours $22.6 Billion Into Four Biggest Banks
- European Firms Plan for Greek Unrest and Euro Exit
MOST POPULAR
HOT ON FACEBOOK
A Secretive Banking Elite Rules Trading in Derivatives
Text Size 
The New York Times
In, Out and Around Henhouse
The result of the maneuvering of the past couple years is that big banks dominate the risk committees of not one, but two of the most prominent new clearinghouses in the United States.
That puts them in a pivotal position to determine how derivatives are traded.
Under the Dodd-Frank bill, the clearinghouses were given broad authority. The risk committees there will help decide what prices will be charged for clearing trades, on top of fees banks collect for matching buyers and sellers, and how much money customers must put up as collateral to cover potential losses.
Perhaps more important, the risk committees will recommend which derivatives should be handled through clearinghouses, and which should be exempt.
Regulators will have the final say. But banks, which lobbied heavily to limit derivatives regulation in the Dodd-Frank bill, are likely to argue that few types of derivatives should have to go through clearinghouses. Critics contend that the bankers will try to keep many types of derivatives away from the clearinghouses, since clearinghouses represent a step towards broad electronic trading that could decimate profits.
The banks already have a head start. Even a newly proposed rule to limit the banks’ influence over clearing allows them to retain majorities on risk committees. It remains unclear whether regulators creating the new rules — on topics like transparency and possible electronic trading — will drastically change derivatives trading, or leave the bankers with great control.
One former regulator warned against deferring to the banks. Theo Lubke, who until this fall oversaw the derivatives reforms at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, said banks do not always think of the market as a whole as they help write rules.
“Fundamentally, the banks are not good at self-regulation,” Mr. Lubke said in a panel last March at Columbia University. “That’s not their expertise, that’s not their primary interest.”
Data is a real-time snapshot *Data is delayed at least 15 minutes
