When Hewlett-Packard executives announced their new mobile lineup of two webOS phones and a tablet on Wednesday, it reminded me of Apple .
Apple 10 years ago, that is.
Back then, Apple had great products, as HP appears to now. The new HP Veer, a petite webOS phone, could easily appeal to the fashionista set (and others with small fingers). The Pre 3 finally has a screen big enough to stand toe-to-toe with the best Android offerings. And the TouchPad tablet has the most refined look and feel of any tablet I've seen besides the iPad. In my hands. I like the TouchPad better than the Motorola Xoom.
HP's challenge will be to turn these solid products into great mobile market share. And I have a feeling HP's going to have a tough time.
For some of the same reasons Apple struggled to gain share in PCs a decade ago. Despite its solid products and reputation with its customer base, mainstream consumers didn't give Apple a second look. Some of that was because of Apple's relatively high prices, but PC buyers also had some entrenched habits. They had old Windows apps they needed to run. Old files they needed to open. Switching to Apple (and paying more to do it) just seemed like too much hassle.
Similarly, HP needs to convince today's mobile consumer — who uses iTunes and Google services to make some changes to embrace webOS devices. HP won't be able to offer the breadth of hardware partners Google has with Android, or the high-end shopping experience and luxury brand Apple has with iOS.
HP does have several advantages. Its Personal Systems Group is a $40.7 billion powerhouse, and its position as the world's biggest PC maker means it has an edge when it comes to securing critical components at a great price. HP already had a relationship with Qualcomm , which will provide processors. It had a relationship with display manufacturers and other chip suppliers. The one area where HP has less pull — flash memory — is one where its experienced operations team should be able to cope. HP also has strong relationships with the big-box retailers who sell PCs, and shouldn't have much trouble securing shelf space there -- especially for the TouchPad.