Combined MPG: 32
Suggested Retail Price: $13,615
KBB Fair Purchase Price: $13,343
Five-year fuel & finance expense: $23,187
The Yaris, the smallest car in Toyota’s lineup, features a “whimsical design” and is “packed with value,” according to the Kelley Blue Book review. It’s not a sporty performer, according to the review, but still fun to drive and great handling, Gutierrez said.