Enter multiple symbols separated by commas

SFO Targets Criminal Company Dividends

The UK’s fraud investigator intends to confiscate shareholder dividends paid by companies convicted of criminal offences, after it won approval for a landmark court action.


The Serious Fraud Office won a civil recovery order on Thursday against the principal shareholder of a company that had admitted corruption.

Mabey Engineering Holding agreed to repay the 131,201 pounds ($201,787) dividend it received from Mabey & Johnson, which built bridges in Iraq and admitted corruption and breaches of UN sanctions in 2009. Two former Mabey & Johnson executives went to prison after the company reported their behavior to the SFO. The agreement, approved by the High Court and seen by the Financial Times, marks the first time that the SFO has tried to recover proceeds of crime by targeting dividends paid in the UK.

While the sum confiscated by the SFO is relatively small, lawyers warned that the precedent it set was potentially huge.

“Under the existing proceeds of crime legislation, the SFO is actually able to do this, which is an alarming proposition for innocent third-party investors,” said Jonathan Fisher QC, a barrister specializing in financial crime. “Intellectually it’s unassailable but if it happened on a large scale it could undermine people’s pension funds.”

Although the case involved a privately held company and its corporate parent, the SFO emphasized that it would not hesitate to pursue third-party investors in listed companies.

“Shareholders and investors in companies are obliged to satisfy themselves with the business practices of the companies they invest in,” said Richard Alderman, director of the SFO. “The SFO intends to use the civil recovery process to pursue investors who have benefited from illegal activity. Where issues arise, we will be much less sympathetic to institutional investors whose due diligence has clearly been lax in this respect.”

Lawyers and investors questioned the SFO’s tactics, arguing that most shareholders can only rely on publicly available information.

“Institutional investors conduct due diligence on companies based on their publicly stated strategy and other public information such as the annual report ,” said one investor. “It is the role of the board, to act on behalf of shareholders in the best long-term interests of the company. Ensuring that the company is not taking part in illegal or improper behavior is clearly part of these responsibilities.”

Peter Lloyd, Mabey Holdings’ chief executive, said: “[The settlement] represents the final chapter in our diligent and painstaking work to root out historic unlawful practices. It represents the culmination of almost four years of close co-operation with the prosecution authorities following our self-referral in 2008.”

Contact Europe News


    Get the best of CNBC in your inbox

    Please choose a subscription

    Please enter a valid email address
    To learn more about how we use your information,
    please read our Privacy Policy.

Europe Video

  • Mobile app success boosts Dominos

    David Wild, CEO of Domino's Pizza Group PLC, talks about getting involved in mobile tech, greater transparency on nutrition and expanding in Europe.

  • Will Russia hold rates on Friday?

    Joseph Dayan, head of markets at BCS Financial Group, explains why he thinks Russia's central bank will "pause and wait" when it comes to cutting interest rates.

  • Yellen has been 'crystal clear' on hikes

    Bob Parker, senior advisor of investment strategy & research at Credit Suisse, lays out expectations on how the U.S. Federal Reserve will hike rates over the next 18 months.