Pension Threat: The Looming Crisis Facing Investors

Thursday, 2 Feb 2012 | 6:41 PM ET

It’s no secret that the financial crisis and resulting malaise has taken its toll on bank stocks, commodities and Treasury yields.

But it may be have triggered another ripple – one that has gone somewhat unnoticed.

Pension funds have become seriously underfunded. According to a recent report from Credit Suisse some of the nation’s largest companies owe their pensions more than 25% of their market cap (after taxes).

Pension Shortfall as Percentage of Market Cap

AK Steel (99%)
ITT (83%)
Goodyear Tire (67%)
United States Steel (59%)
Sears (43%)
Lockheed Martin (39%)
Supervalu (39%)
Computer Sciences (37%)
Whirlpool (33%)
Ford Motor (32%)
Alcoa (30%)
Donnelley (29%)
Textron (27%)
Raytheon (25%)
Source: Credit Suisse

Although the problem is complex, at its core is simple math. Many firms forecast returns of 8% annually. And that just hasn't happened.

Looming Corporate Pension Shortfalls
Companies in the S&P will face a 36% pension shortfall this year. John Ehrhardt Milliman, Fastline, explains.

This developing situation is potentially market moving because it could require companies to make larger contributions – much larger. And if contributions ‘do’ go up, the money will have to come from someplace on the balance sheet.

“A pension accounting change at UPS will result in $527 million after tax charge in 2011,” says Joe Terranova. "And Sunoco said they have to contribute $80 million into their pension funds."

In other words, the need to fund pensions could drag down profits and, in turn, share price.

In fact, the pension liability at AK Steel was cited by BofA as a reason behind their recent decision to downgrade the stock to ‘Underperform’ from ‘Neutral.”

“I think in 2012 it will be a recurring issue,” Terranova says.

John Ehrhardt of Milliman confirms the thesis. He tells us that investors should expect record numbers of earnings charges in 2012.

“Record low interest rates result in historically high liabilities and the only remaining lever may be employer contributions.”

And according to Ehrhardt this may be just the tip of the iceberg. "These companies are going to need 20-30% returns to fill the kinds of gaps we're talking about."

Got something to to say? Send us an e-mail at fastmoney-web@cnbc.com and your comment might be posted on the Rapid Recap. If you'd prefer to make a comment, but not have it published on our Web site, send those e-mails to fastmoney@cnbc.com.

Trader disclosure: On Feb. 2, 2012, the following stocks and commodities mentioned or intended to be mentioned on CNBC’s "Fast Money" were owned by the "Fast Money" traders: Terranova is long GOOG; Terranova is long JOY; Terranova is long TRLG; Terranova is long AXP; Terranova is long MUB; Terranova is long LQD; Terranova is long SBUX; Terranova is long CNX; Terranova is long SU; Terranova is long OXY; Terranova is long MA; Terranova is long MCD; Terranova is long SNDK; Terranova is long EMC; Terranova is long IBM; Terranova is long VRTS; Najarian is long AAPL; Najarian is long BAC; Najarian is long PNC; Najarian is long GS; Najarian is long GDX; Najarian is long MSFT; Najarian is long AK; Najarian is long PCX; Najarian is long RSE; Kelly is long GLD; Kelly is long TLT; Kelly is long XLF; Kelly is long KRE; Kelly is long KOL; Kelly is long SLX; Kelly is long XHB; Kelly is long MHK; Kelly is long USG; Kelly is long SPY puts; Kelly is short Yen;

For Ron Insana
No disclosures

For Mike Khouw
No disclosures

For Carter Worth
Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. makes a market in the securities of GOOG.
Oppenheimer & Co. Inc. makes a market in the securities of MSFT.

For John Ehrhardt
No disclosures

For Dan Dicker
Dicker is long SD
Dicker is long SDT

CNBC.com with wires.

Contact Fast Money

  • Showtimes

    Halftime Report - Weekdays 12p ET
    Fast Money - Weekdays 5p ET
  • Melissa Lee is the host of CNBC's “Fast Money” and “Options Action.”

  • Scott Wapner is host of the "Fast Money Halftime Report," which airs weekdays from 12 p.m. to 1 p.m. ET.

  • Guy Adami is a contributor on CNBC's "Fast Money." He also is managing director of stockMONSTER.com.

  • Najarian, the "Pit Boss," is cofounder of optionMONSTER.com, a news site for options traders.

  • Finerman is president of Metropolitan Capital Advisors, Inc., a company she co-founded.

  • Founder of EmergingMoney.com

  • Chief Market Strategist for Virtus Investment Partners & CNBC Contributor

Halftime Report

  • Jay Yarow, The Business Insider, and Steve Milunovich, UBS, discuss whether Tim Cook is to blame for Apple's drop in growth. I think it's pretty clear they missed the big phone market and overestimated the success of the plastic 5C phone, says Milunovich.

  • CNBC's Eamon Javers reports on Bill Ackman's stake in Allergan. Javers says this is a classic case of insider trading that is not against the rules.

  • FMHR trader Josh Brown thinks Dunkin' Brands looks fantastic technically, while Mike Murphy says investors are questioning the company's massive expansion plans.