GO
Loading...

Supreme Court Hears Arguments on Limiting Lawsuits

AP

The Supreme Court appears ready to impose new limits on lawsuits brought in U.S. courts against companies over human rights violations abroad.

The justices kicked off their new term Monday with arguments over whether businesses and individuals can be sued in the United States for conduct that takes place on foreign soil and has foreign victims.

The dispute involves a lawsuit filed against Royal Dutch Petroleum over claims that the oil company was complicit in abuses committed by the Nigerian government against its citizens in the oil-rich Niger Delta.

Justice Samuel Alito said the case has no connection to this country and wondered why it should "belong in the courts of the United States?"

The court also declined to hear an appeal from a national anti-gay marriage group that tried to thwart Maine's campaign disclosure law requiring it to release its donor list.

The high court turned aside an appeal from the National Organization for Marriage, which donated $1.9 million to a political action committee that helped repeal Maine's same-sex marriage law.

Maine's campaign disclosure law requires groups that raise or spend more than $5,000 to influence elections to register and disclose donors. The group says it believes releasing the donor list would stymie free speech, but the lower court refused to throw out the law.

The case is pending with the state ethics commission, so the voter list remains under wraps. Voters repealed the Maine's gay marriage law in 2009.

Contact U.S. News

  • CNBC NEWSLETTERS

    Get the best of CNBC in your inbox

    Please choose a subscription

    Please enter a valid email address
    To learn more about how we use your information,
    please read our Privacy Policy.

Don't Miss

U.S. Video

  • CNBC's Simon Hobbs reports on all the market moving events in Europe today, including Greece and the move on the euro.

  • CNBC's Josh Lipton gives insight on how sellers can benefit from taking an off market approach to selling their home. Brokers say that 2015 could see a record number of off market sales in San Francisco, says Lipton.

  • Insight into Apple with Daniel Ives, FBR Capital Markets, discussing Apple watch launch and where the company is headed.