Hedgie Says China Fraud Trade Over—Short Tech
Senior Editor, CNBC.com
Sure, Whitney Tilson probably captured the most attention Monday morning with his claim that Netflix is at least as good a business as Amazon was in 2001.
(Read more: Netflix ‘A Real Global Growth Opportunity’: Tilson)
But the most intriguing idea came from a relatively unknown young hedge-fund manager named Zack Buckley.
Buckley, who runs Buckley Capital out of Miami, titled his talk Monday at the Value Investing Congress "Is it 1999 Again?" His thesis: that the best trades out there are likely to be tech shorts.
Buckley began with a bit of biography. He became a short-seller after being long several Chinese companies. After he had invested in those companies, he traveled to China to check out his investments.
What he found was horrific: manufacturing companies that were empty warehouses, a pig farm with no mature pigs at all, and so on. (Read more: Greece Is Better Investment Than China Right Now)
Company after company he visited turned out to be nothing like what they had held themselves out to be. He wound up selling all his positions and shorting several of those companies.
Shorting China frauds, however, is also "played out," in Buckley's view.
The obvious frauds have already been uncovered. There are very few public companies that are empty warehouses these days. Some questionable companies will no doubt be uncovered, but frauds in Chinese companies are now much harder to detect and it is less certain that they will eventually be exposed. (Read more: Holiday Gifts and China Graft Challenge)
So Buckley has turned to tech. Hence the title of his talk: it is 1999 all over again. There are tech companies that are severely overvalued, he argued. Their stock prices will fall.
Buckley singled out Splunk, a software platform company, as his short target. You can read about his argument against Splunk over at Business Insider. But what struck me as more interesting was this dynamic: the short-seller in search of the next overvalued sector.
We had real estate and home builders, then financial companies, then China. Now the young cool kids are turning against tech.
-by CNBC.com senior editor John Carney
We're on Google Plus too! Click here for John's Google+ page.
Questions? Comments? Tips? Email us atNetNet@cnbc.comor send a text message to: 917-740-8477.
Call us at 201-735-4638.