Storm Recovery Could Take Weeks as Millions Struggle

CNBC.com with wires
Wednesday, 31 Oct 2012 | 4:35 PM ET

Wall Street and two major airports reopened, and National Guardsmen rushed to rescue flood victims as the Northeast limped into recovery mode Wednesday, two days after being pummeled by epic Hurricane Sandy.

Brendan Smialowski | AFP | Getty Images

For the first time since the storm battered the Northeast, killing at least 59 people and doing billions of dollars in damage, brilliant sunshine washed over the nation's largest city — a striking sight after days of gray skies, rain and wind.

Millions of people in New York City and other hard-hit areas will spend days or weeks recovering from the storm already seen as far more destructive than Hurricane Irene, which slammed into the same region a year ago.

Some early estimates of damage were at $50 billion, making it one of the costliest storms in U.S. history.

(Read More: Sandy's Economic Cost: $50 Billion and Counting)

At the New York Stock Exchange, running on generator power, Mayor Michael Bloomberg gave a thumbs-up and rang the opening bell to whoops from traders on the floor. Trading resumed after the first two-day weather shutdown since the Blizzard of 1888.

(Read More: Stock Market Back to Business After Sandy Setback)

"Sandy hit us very hard," Bloomberg told reporters, "but New Yorkers are resilient."

He later announced restrictions on auto travel — between 6 a.m. and midnight, cars need at least three occupants to cross over East River bridges and tunnels and the Lincoln Tunnel.


New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo said limited service would return Wednesday afternoon to suburban commuter train lines, and on Thursday to the city's subway system, which suffered the worst damage in its 108-year history. All 10 of the tunnels that carry commuters under the East River were flooded.

In Washington, the Labor Department said it would release the monthly employment report as scheduled Friday. A two-day government shutdown had threatened to delay the data, the last jobs report before Tuesday's presidential election.

Kennedy and Newark Liberty airports reopened with limited service just after 7 a.m. New York's LaGuardia Airport, which suffered far worse damage and where water covered parts of runways, remained closed. Airlines canceled more than 19,500 flights.

(Read More: For Travelers, Sandy's Aggravation Spans Globe)

Across the Hudson River from Manhattan, National Guard troops arrived in the heavily flooded city of Hoboken to help evacuate thousands still stuck in their homes and deliver ready-to-eat meals.

Live wires dangled in floodwaters that Mayor Dawn Zimmer said were rapidly mixing with sewage. Thousands of people were still holed up in their brownstones, condos, and other homes in the mile-square city.

New Jersey Picks Up the Pieces After Super Storm Sandy
Wall Street prepares to reopen for business today after one of the most devastating storms in US history; at least 44 are now reported dead and millions are still without power in New York and New Jersey. Ron Allen has this update for us.

Super storm Sandy's victims included 18 people in New York City, and a total of 23 in New York state, while six died in New Jersey. Seven other states reported fatalities.

About 6.5 million homes and businesses were still without power, including 4 million in New York and New Jersey. Electricity was out as far west as Wisconsin and as far south as the Carolinas.

In a sign that the problems created from Sandy were far from over, firefighters battled a fire at a sewage treatment plant on Long Island in New York.

The blaze started around 1:30 a.m. Wednesday at the Bay Park sewage treatment plant in East Rockaway. Officials said at least six fire departments were on the scene.

Fire ravaged the Breezy Point neighborhood in the borough of Queens, destroying 110 homes and damaging 20 while destroying still more in the nearby neighborhood of Belle Harbor. Remarkably, no fatalities were reported there.

"To describe it as looking like pictures we've seen of the end of World War II is not overstating it," Bloomberg said after touring the area.

  • Click here for dramatic video of the fire
  • Spencer Platt

    The Brooklyn Bridge was closed a day earlier because of high winds. But on Wednesday, joggers and bikers made their way across before sunrise. One cyclist carried a flashlight. Car traffic was brisk but slowed going into Manhattan.

    But high water prevented inspectors from immediately assessing damage to key equipment, raising the possibility that the nation's largest city could endure an extended shutdown of the system that 5 million people count on to get to work and school each day.

    The chairman of the state agency that runs New York's subways, Joseph Lhota, said service might have to resume piecemeal, and experts said the cost of the repairs could be staggering.

    Consolidated Edison said it would be four days before the last of the 337,000 customers in Manhattan and Brooklyn who lost power have electricity again and it could take a week to restore outages in the Bronx, Queens, Staten Island and Westchester County.

    Floodwater led to explosions that disabled a power substation Monday night, contributing to the outages.

    Amtrak announced that modified service along the Northeast Corridor would resume Thursday outside of New York. It said it hoped to restore service to New York City on Friday.

    In Pennsylvania, Gov. Tom Corbett cited reported that Philadelphia's mass transit system were slowly coming back.

    In Washington, the Smithsonian Institution's museums and National Zoo were reopening after shutting for two days.

    Surveying the widespread damage, it was clear much of the recovery and rebuilding will take far longer.

    When New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie stopped in Belmar, N.J., during a tour of the devastation, one woman wept openly and 42-year-old Walter Patrickis told him, "Governor, I lost everything."

    Photo by Justin Solomon for CNBC.com

    Christie, who called the shore damage "unthinkable," said a full recovery would take months, at least, and it would likely be a week or more before power is restored to everyone who lost it.

    Sandy was the biggest storm to hit the region in generations when it crashed ashore with hurricane-force winds on Monday near the New Jersey gambling resort of Atlantic City, devastating the Jersey Shore tourist haven.

    Flood waters lifted parked cars and deposited them on an otherwise deserted highway.

    Election Impact

    With the political campaign and partisanship on hold, President Barack Obama and Republican Christie toured New Jersey disaster areas on Wednesday.

    Getty Images

    "It's total devastation down there. There are boats in the street five blocks from the ocean," said Peter Sandomeno, an owner of the Broadway Court Motel in Point Pleasant Beach, N.J.

    Christie, who has been a strong supporter of Republican presidential challenger Mitt Romney, praised Obama and the federal response to the storm.

    (Read More: Obama and Christie Make Unlikely Traveling Companions)

    Obama and Romney put campaigning on hold for a second day but Romney hit the trail again in Florida on Wednesday and Obama seemed likely to resume campaigning on Thursday for a final five-day sprint to Election Day.

    (Read More: Obama to Visit Storm Victims as Campaign Resumes)

    "This is the biggest challenge we've ever had," said George R. Gilmore, chairman of the Ocean County Board of Elections.

    Obama faces political danger if the government fails to respond well, as was the case with predecessor George W. Bush's botched handling of Hurricane Katrina in 2005.

    (Read More: October Surprise: Sandy Blows in on Final Days of Election)

    Obama has a chance to show that his administration has learned the lessons of Katrina and that he can lead during a crisis.

    "What the hurricane has done, not by intent, is give the president the opportunity to be presidential and to play that role very visibly," Sam Chandan, chief economist at Chandan Economics in New York told CNBC.

    "Folks have been able to watch him on TV every evening, he's played that commander-in-chief role, so it may actually help them going into next week," Chandan said.

    New York Under Water

    Sandy brought a record storm surge of almost 14 feet (4.2 meters) to downtown Manhattan, well above the previous record of 10 feet (3 meters) during Hurricane Donna in 1960, the National Weather Service said.

    New York City postponed its traditional Halloween parade, which had been set for Wednesday night in Greenwich Village. Christie also postpone Halloween trick-or-treating in New Jersey until Monday. (Read More: For New Jersey, Halloween Won't Come Until Monday)

    Also postponed: the NBA's debut in Brooklyn in a season-opening contest Thursday night between the Nets and the New York Knicks at the new Barclays Center. But Bloomberg said Sunday's New York City Marathon would go on as planned.


    The lower half of Manhattan went dark when surging seawater flooded a substation and as power utility Consolidated Edison shut down others pre-emptively. Some 250,000 customers lost power.

    The parts of the city that are without power are seeing increased police patrols and other stepped-up security measures as they face the prospect of days without electricity. Officials said power might not be back until the weekend for hundreds of thousands of people.

    There was no sign of looting or widespread crime, although about a dozen people were arrested in Coney Island and Queens on charges of trying to steal from shops, a pharmacy and the bank, where the entire front was missing.

    Hospitals closed throughout the region, forcing patients to relocate and doctors to carry premature babies down more than a dozen flights of stairs at one New York City facility.

    While some parts of the city went unscathed, neighborhoods along the East and Hudson rivers bordering Manhattan were underwater and expected to be without power for days, as were low-lying streets in Battery Park near Ground Zero, where the World Trade Center stood before the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks.

    "I'm lucky to have gas; I can make hot water. But there is no heating and I'm all cold inside," said Thea Lucas, 87, who lives alone in Manhattan's Lower East Side.

    Economic Cost

    While there were still only hints of the economic impact of the storm by Tuesday, AIR Worldwide estimated losses up to $15 billion — big numbers probably offset by reconstruction and repairs that will contribute to longer-term growth.

    Andrew Economos, head of sovereign and institutional strategy for Asia at JP Morgan Asset Management, said the cost from the storm damage could be as high as $50 billion.

    "We expect anywhere from $20 to $30 billion in losses, with upside of $50 billion," he told CNBC. "The good news is that the U.S. has proven time and time again that it can recover quickly given a fairly flexible economy and robust labor force."

    Other analysts said any negative impact on the economy would be limited.

    "Clearly the bounce back from these situations is relatively quick, people are insured and there is a reason to buy durables, so the negative impact on the economy from the storm will not be that significant," Uwe Parpart, managing director and head of research at Reorient Financial Markets, told CNBC Asia's "Cash Flow" on Wednesday.

    Stephen Schwartz, chief economist for Asia at BBVA, agreed, adding: "We're still obviously watching for the damage and seeing how it unfolds. At this stage I think it's pretty clear it's going to shave off a bit of GDP growth in the fourth quarter, but we don think at this stage it really changes our outlook for the U.S. economy."

    Photo by Adam Jeffery for CNBC.com

    According to Frank Holmes, CEO at U.S. Global Investors fund management, the boost to the economy from reconstruction spending could be bigger than anticipated.

    "There'll be a tremendous amount of spending and activity so there'll be a focused spending program to update and replenish a lot of old infrastructure. That's the positive part," he told CNBC.

    Destruction Throughout Region

    Cellphone service went silent in many states and some emergency call centers were affected.

    Some cities like Washington, Philadelphia and Boston were mostly spared but the storm reached as far inland as Ohio and parts of West Virginia were buried under 3 feet (1 meter) of snow, a boon for ski resorts that was one of the storm's few bright spots.

    (Read More: Sandy Knocks Out 25% Cell Towers Serving 10 States)

    The western extreme of Sandy's wind field buffeted the Great Lakes region, according to Andrew Krein of the National Weather Service, generating wind gusts of up to 60 mph (96 kph) on the southern end of Lake Michigan and up to 35 mph (56 kph) in Chicago.

    In Cleveland, buildings in the city's downtown area were evacuated due to flooding, police said.

    Winds gusting to 50 mph (80 kph) brought down wires and knocked out power to homes and business.

    City officials asked residents to stay inside and for downtown businesses to remained closed for the day.

    Amid the devastation there was opportunity. Snowmakers at Snowshoe Mountain in the mountains of West Virginia had their equipment running at full speed on Tuesday, taking advantage of the cold temperatures to build the 24-30 inch (61-76 cm) base they need to open for skiing by Thanksgiving.

    Devastations From Sandy
    Meteorologist Todd Gross reports there are signs of Sandy re-strengthening. Assessing the damages from Sandy, with CNBC's Scott Cohn, Kayla Tausche and Mary Thompson; and Rep. Peter King (R-NY), discusses the devastation in New York due to the superstorm.

    "There are snowmakers out there making snow in what was a hurricane and blizzard," said Dave Dekema, marketing director for the resort, which received a foot-and-a-half (45 cm) of snow, with another foot or 2 (30 to 60 cm) expected.

    The resort's phones, email account and Facebook pages were "going crazy," Dekema said, with avid skiers and snowboarders wondering if there was any chance of getting out on the mountain this weekend. He said that was unlikely.



      Name Price   Change %Change Volume
    US GAS


      Name Name Name Name Name


      Name Price   Change %Change Volume


      Name Price   Change %Change Volume


      Name Price   Change %Change Volume


      Name Price   Change %Change Volume


      Name Price   Change %Change Volume

    Reuters and AP contributed to this report


    Contact U.S. News


      Get the best of CNBC in your inbox

      › Learn More

    Don't Miss

    U.S. Video