Asia Economy

The US Needs a Recession: Economist

Geraldine Tan|Assistant Producer, CNBC Asia Pacific
Mike Kemp  | Getty Images

The trillions of dollars the Federal Reserve has thrown at the U.S. economy has done little to lift the country out of its doldrums; unemployment remains high, consumer spending weak and the housing sector looks set for a double dip.

As the government struggles to stave off another recession, one expert suggests that a period of economic decline may be exactly what the U.S. needs to turn things around.

“For the last two years, it has been perfectly clear that we cannot lift ourselves out of this recession,” says Graeme Maxton, chief economist at The Insight Bureau told CNBC Thursday. “We need to actually have a recession. We need to burn off the debt.”

Maxton cautions against pouring more money into the U.S. economy. Policymakers have so far poured in $5 trillion into the economy via various stimulus measures and generated growth of $600 billion, he says.

“That is a pretty bad investment. And we have still got a situation where consumer debt is almost as high as it was, bank debt was almost as high as it was and then we have government debt,” said Maxton. “It is wasted money. We have to go through the economic pain.”

Investors’ assumption that growth is going to come back and that oil prices will stay at the current levels, or lower, have been supporting the U.S. stock markets which Maxton believes is “hugely over-valued.”

What Will QE3 Mean?

“Neither of those (assumptions) is going to happen. We are going to see the economy slowing. Consumption cannot come back because people have borrowed themselves to oblivion,” the economist said, adding that the global markets have under-priced the world’s resources by selling them cheap.

Maxton warns that Asia will not be immune to the U.S. slowdown as a drop in consumption in America and in Europe will have a global knock-on effect — impacting employment in China and share prices.

“If you are in Asia, the issue is not so much that you are going to have a recession or a long, slow period of decline, which is what we are facing in the West. It is that we are going to see lower growth. Instead of 6-9 percent growth, Asian countries are going to have to get use to 3-6 percent growth.”

Asian countries will need to adjust their growth models, as they are not going to be able to achieve the rate of economic progress that they’ve had before, Maxton adds.

While he expects China’s economy and the region’s domestic consumption to see “lots of growth”, it is not enough to make up for the shortfall from the U.S. and Europe.