The Guest Blog

Rotblut: When Good Funds Have Bad Performance

Charles Rotblut, CFA|VP, American Association of Individual Investors

Even good mutual fund managers can have bad quarters.

Such was the case last quarter for Bruce Berkowitz of Fairholme, which ranked among the worst-performing domestic stock funds covered by our Quarterly Low-Load Mutual Fund Update. FAIRX lost 7.3% last quarter and is now down 9.5% year-to-date. Disappointing results, but they follow years of comparatively strong performance. Fairholme topped its domestic peers on an annual basis for nearly all of the past decade.

Gregor Schuster | Getty Images

When looking at a mutual fund with a good long-term record but lackluster recent performance, the first question to ask is “has anything changed?” The answer often rests on one of four characteristics: management, objective, size and external factors.

An actively managed mutual fund’s performance is often tied to the talent of its managers. Any time a successful fund manager departs, future performance needs to be scrutinized more closely. Some funds enjoy a successful transition and others do not.

A change in a fund’s objective can give a manager more flexibility for picking investments, but it can result in different return characteristics. Investors need to read their fund’s prospectus annually to check for any changes.

Size can create headaches for a fund following a specific strategy. This occurs when assets under management (AUM) exceed the amount a manager can effectively deploy. It can be a problem for funds that target certain foreign markets, specific industry groups or smaller companies with less trading volume. It also has the potential to be a problem for funds like Fairholme that hold a limited number of stocks (FAIRX holds just 20 stocks and seven bonds), but you need consider the average volume of each holding (aka liquidity) before viewing a concentrated portfolio as a red flag.

External factors are market and economic changes that work against a fund manager. Several gold funds, including U.S. Global Investors World Precious Minerals and Midas , posted double-digit percentage declines last quarter because mining stocks fell in value. It does not matter how good a manager is; if the category he invests in performs poorly, his fund’s returns will suffer.

The most important factor is to think about why you bought the mutual fund in the first place. Most mutual funds, including Fairholme, are intended to be held for the long term. There are some that are intended for tactical, short-term speculation, such as Direxion Monthly Dollar Bull 2x Investor and Rydex Investor S&P 500 2x Strategy. The two types of funds should not be confused. If you own a fund that follows a long-term strategy and nothing significant has changed (e.g., objective, management, size, etc.), you should not be worried by a short period of poor performance if the fund has a lengthy record of good returns. On the other hand, if you are buying a fund for purely short-term trading, be prepared to sell it quickly and do not treat it as a long-term position. Countless investors have hurt their portfolio’s performance by entangling short-term speculation with long-term investing.

This Week’s Gratis Tip

As important as performance statistics are, you will need to look beyond the numbers to determine whether a particular mutual fund is a good investment for the future. Beyond the Numbers: Getting to Know a Managerlists 10 questions you should ask when evaluating a fund.

The Week Ahead

Nearly 100 members of the S&P 500 will release second-quarter earnings next week. Dow components Bank of America, Coca-Cola and Johnson & Johnson will report on Tuesday. American Express, Intel, and United Technologies will report Wednesday. The Travelers Companies will report on Thursday, and Caterpillar, General Electric and Verizon will report on Friday.

Earnings Stocks to Watch

Switching to the economic calendar, the National Association of Home Builders’ July housing market index will be published on Monday. Tuesday will feature June housing starts and building permits. June existing home sales data will be released on Wednesday. Thursday will feature the July Philadelphia Federal Reserve survey and The Conference Board’s June leading indicators index.

The Treasury Department will auction $13 billion of 10-year inflation-protected securities (TIPS) on Thursday.

Kansas City Federal Reserve Bank President Thomas Hoenig will speak publicly on Tuesday.

Charles Rotblut, CFA is a Vice President with the and editor of the AAII Journal.