» more from Slideshows

10. 2013 Toyota Scion tC

Resale Value at 36 months: 60%
Resale Value at 60 months: 46.5%

The tC has consistently been the best-selling model in Toyota's youth-oriented Scion division. The Kelley Blue Book website describes the coupe as a "small two-door with a surprisingly roomy backseat."

Kelley Blue Book cites a starting price of approximately $20,000, making it an ideal choice for the young driver who doesn't have a lot to spend. Ibara said that despite this car's reputation as "a niche vehicle," it should retain its value over the years.