Mad Money

After controversial ‘sell case’ American Tower goes 'Mad'

AMT Corp. CEO on Muddy Waters report
AMT Corp. CEO on Muddy Waters report

(Click for video linked to a searchable transcript of this Mad Money segment)

On Wednesday, landed on Cramer's radar after a firm known for short selling suggested the stock was significantly overvalued.

Immediately American Tower went 'Mad.'

That is the company's CEO James Taiclet turned to Mad Money with Jim Cramer to set the record straight.


In a somewhat controversial note posted on its website, the investment firm Muddy Water cited a slew of negative catalysts which they believe have not been factored into the stock price.

Those catalysts ranged from a belief that international growth will not benefit this company as expected, to potential accounting discrepancies involving transactions in Brazil.

The firm also cited insider selling from CEO James Taiclet, which Muddy Waters interpreted as a lack of faith in the sustainability of the business.

Read More from Mad Money with Jim Cramer
With momentum stalling, time to worry?
Chart patterns suggest laggard transforming into leader
Energy stock's price action classic 'bull' tell

Due to these and other catalysts, Muddy Waters wrote, "We rate American Tower a strong sell and value it at $44.57 per share, representing downside of 40%."

Communication Tower
Michael Betts | Photographer's Choice | Getty Images


American Tower CEO James Taiclet told Cramer the allegations and inferences made by Muddy Waters are 'completely wrong.'

"Normally we wouldn't respond to such an ill-informed report but it's completely wrong and the associated allegation of fraud is something we couldn't let stand."

Among the more serious issues is a suggestion of accounting discrepancies. Taiclet however says the Muddy Waters report writer didn't fully understand the way in which the company funded its transactions in Latin America, which he said was reviewed by top accounting firms.

And he added, "we intend to provide to the SEC any and all bank records needed to set the matter straight. In fact, we are filing a formal 8K with the SEC to lay out all the facts."

On a related note, Taiclet also told Cramer his stock sales. "are part of a a standard selling plan as new options come in each year."

Cramer's Insights

"You have to draw your own conclusion," Cramer said. "But I regard the Muddy Waters reports as inflammatory. And I want you to know that if the company files an 8k with the SEC and it's not in fact true, the company will face consequences. "

Call Cramer: 1-800-743-CNBC

Questions for Cramer?

Questions, comments, suggestions for the "Mad Money" website?