Net Net: Promoting innovation and managing change
Net Net: Promoting innovation and managing change

Inside hedge fund pay: $10M for a 10 percent return

Ericsphotography | E+ | Getty Images

It's no secret that people can make a lot of money working in finance. Top hedge and private equity fund chief investment officers can earn several billion dollars in a single year—David Tepper of Appaloosa Management earned an estimated $2.2 billion in 2012, for example.

But reports on big paydays tend to focus on CIOs. What's less explored is how much the No. 2 can make.

A lot.

The executive in charge of running the firm without making investments—usually called the CEO, chief operating officer or president—can expect to haul down between $7 million and $10 million if the fund returns just 10 percent for investors and manages about $5 billion.

That's according to new research from executive search firm Boyden that looked at the compensation of CEOs at hedge funds, business development corporations (a type of private equity fund) and boutique investment banks.

(Read more: Ackman: Target's 'lost magic'...and other thoughts)

If performance and assets increase, the pay is even greater, Boyden said, and CEOs can earn $15 million or more.

Traditional hedge CEO compensation has three parts. For the No. 2 at a firm managing $5 billion with a 10 percent return, typical base compensation would be $500,000 to $1 million; a fixed bonus based on the management fee charged to investors of $1 million to $2 million; and an incentive bonus based on the performance of the fund, perhaps $5 million to $10 million but with no cap.

A 10 percent gain isn't rare: The average hedge fund was up 9.21 percent in 2013, according to data from HedgeFund Intelligence.

Hedge fund targets

It's not all easy money. The survey notes that more asset management firms have so-called claw backs on compensation if the firm does well one year but crashes the next. More innovation compensation structures award a larger percentage of pay based on assets raised—or lost—and investment performance as opposed to fixed bonuses.

While uncomfortable for old-school executives, investors in hedge and other funds like the increased use of deferred compensation and other performance-tied bonuses.

"The trend toward performance-based incentive is going to unseat some seemingly comfortable CEOs as the boards of these firms become more progressive and in-tune with the changing incentive trends," said Kate Quinn, the Boyden partner who assembled the report.

"Yesterday's CEOs are not in demand," she said. "The market is looking for skin in the game and CEOs with the ability to wear many hats. We're seeing a noticeable trend that will change the market for certain."

(Read more: Did short sellers rebounds after crushing 2013 losses?)

Past Boyden clients, according to the report, include Tudor Investment, Fortress Investment Group, Goldman Sachs, Magnetar Capital and Morgan Stanley.

—By CNBC's Lawrence Delevingne. Follow him on Twitter @ldelevingne.

More In Net Net: Promoting innovation and managing change

CNBC ProCisco Systems CEO talks Acacia deal, 5g infrastructure, Capitol riot
watch now
CNBC ProHoneywell CEO discusses partnership to ramp up Covid vaccinations in North Carolina