Fast Money Halftime Report

Monday - Friday, 12:00 - 1:00 PM ET

Fast Money Halftime Report

5-star stock picker Bill Nygren’s new plays

Bill Nygren's new ideas
Bill Nygren's new ideas

While stocks aren't as cheap as they were a year ago, Oakmark Funds' Bill Nygren said Tuesday that there are still attractive buys out there—and he revealed four new portfolio additions.

"Relative to our style, investors are almost always overweighting near-term events," he said. "We don't see the potential we did five years ago, when stocks have tripled from the bottom. But over the next five to seven years, when you compare the alternatives of stocks, cash or bonds, to us stocks look substantially better."

The Oakmark Fund earned a five-star rating from Morningstar and had $12.2 billion in assets as of Dec. 31. Nygren oversees a total of $13 billion in assets.

On "Halftime Report," Nygren said that Citigroup, a new holding for the fund, sells at a discount.

"You can still buy Citi at 80 percent of tangible book value and, we think, about eight times recovery earnings, assuming interest rates go up a little bit," he said.

Read MoreFour stocks to buy on a dip: Analyst

Nygren sounded positive on financials as a sector.

"At Oakmark, our favorite industry for the past couple of years has been financials, and it continues to be," he said. "We think that especially the banks are very cheap. Most of them now have excess capital. And most of them have the mentality that if they don't get loan growth, they're going to grow through shrinking the denominator, share repurchase."

The three other new stocks Nygren added to the fund were different than Citi, he noted.

"They tend to be the stocks that the frustrated fixed income buyers had bid up to what we thought was too-expensive levels early in 2013," he said, adding that the three other new stocks for the fund in the past quarter were General Mills, Sanofi and Diageo.

"All three, we think, are exceptionally good businesses, sell at 15 to 17 next year's EPS, pay a 2 to 3 percent dividend yield," he said. "So, we think of those names as being far better than average but selling for about average multiples and has the nice kicker that the dividend yield about matches what you could get on the 10-year bond."

After a decline in its yogurt business, General Mills stock has likely bottomed, Nygren said, adding that a cereal joint venture with Nestle had strong emerging market exposure. "We think that asset is undervalued by most investors and creates a better growth opportunity for General Mills than most people appreciate," he said.

Nygren also said he was sticking with General Motors, despite its recent woes.

"We think that within a couple of years they should be able to earn $6 a share, makes it a very low P/E for this market," he said. "We think GM will regain its market share if they lose some because of the current PR environment."

By CNBC's Bruno J. Navarro.