Judge: JC Penney interfered with Martha Stewart-Macy's deal

David Becker / Contributor | Getty Images Entertainment

J.C. Penney interfered with Macy's agreement with Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia, a New York judge ruled on Monday.

Justice Jeffrey Oing of New York state court referred the issue of damages to a referee or special hearing officer.

Read MoreMartha Stewart dumped by JC Penney CEO Mike Ullman—report

But, he said in his written ruling, "Macy's failed to prove by 'clear, unequivocal and convincing evidence' that it is entitled to a punitive damage award."

Macy's sued Penney and Martha Stewart Living after the two announced a partnership in December 2011. Macy's said the agreement breached its contract with Martha Stewart that included exclusive rights to Martha Stewart-branded cookware, bedding and bath products.

Read More Martha Stewart: It's all about branding

In October, Penney and Martha Stewart Living announced a revised agreement that eliminated Stewart's products in home goods categories to which Macy's claimed exclusive rights.

—By Reuters

Read MoreMartha Stewart's JC Penney Deal Left Macy's CEO 'Sick'