Top Stories
Top Stories
Law and Regulations

The big business of selling apps to prison inmates

Profiting from prisons

The United States has the highest incarceration rate in the world, with about 5 percent of the world's population, but 25 percent of the world's prisoners.

For some businessmen, that represents a big money-making opportunity, and few can attest to that better than Ryan Shapiro, CEO of JPay, a company that provides various services for inmates.

"Our goal is to become the nation's digital consumer app company for prisons," Shapiro told CNBC.

JPay got its start in 2002 by offering electronic money transfers for inmates. This way, inmates' families could transfer money to a prisoner's account via computer or smartphone instead of leaving their homes to send a money order.

Those money transfers represent the bulk of JPay's business—about $50 million in revenue last year—but the company also offers services like email, tablets, video visitation and music downloading. (It's now piloting an e-books program in a prison in Ohio.) JPay has been profitable since 2006, and processed over $500 million in 2013, said Shapiro.

Helping JPay's business is the fact that it has a near-monopoly for providing these services. The company now operates in 32 states and over 1,200 facilities nationwide, servicing about 1.7 million inmates.

The invisible handcuffs

Source: North Dakota State Penitentiary

From the wire to hi-tech wiring

JPay’s primary money transfer service is available in 32 states, but it’s looking to help inmates reach the world beyond the prison walls in additional ways.

Its email services are now available in 16 states. Its media services, including tablets and music media devices, are now in eight states. Video chats, or video “visitation” is available in five states.

Washington, North Dakota, Georgia and Ohio are the only states to offer all four JPay technologies.

The demographics of the prison system show why the invisible hand of capitalism has created a thriving prison marketplace …

Source: Thinkstock | Stockbyte | Getty Images

We’re better than China at this

The U.S. has the largest prison population in the world, more than held behind bars in China, more than ever held in Stalin’s gulags, but just how much of the U.S. does the prison population represent?

The total U.S. correctional population—which includes local facilities and private facilities in addition to federal and state penitentiaries, and those on probation or parole—had reached 6.94 million people at year-end 2012—2.9 percent of the U.S. adult population, or 1 in 35 U.S. adults, according to the Department of Justice. One out of every 100 adults in America is actually behind bars.

At year-end 2013, the federal and state prison system together housed near-1.6 million individuals.

Source: Jesus Gonzalez | Flickr | Getty Images

Caring for the incarcerated

State expenditures on the incarcerated grew from $15 billion to $53.5 billion from 1982 to 2001, and have hovered near-$50 billion in recent years, representing between 1.9 percent and 3.3 percent of states’ total spending, according to a DOJ analysis released in 2012.

The prison population has at least one thing in common with the rest of the country: an aging demographic that is a growing medical burden.

Medical expenditures as part of prison spending have been on the rise: between 2001 and 2008, thirty-five of 44 states to report data on expenditures showed an increase in medical spending on inmates; five states reported an increase of 100 percent or more, according to DOJ data.

California spent the most of any state per inmate on medical expenses, $11,986, between 2001 and 2008. Illinois spent the least, at $2,317.

Source: David Madison | Getty Images

Big house billions

JPay is not the only company to try and get over the prison walls and into the lucrative prison market.

Concessions giant Aramark, which runs everything from stadium food stands to National Park Service facilities, has a huge presence in prison meals.

Two publicly traded companies, The GEO Group and Corrections Corp of America, together generated over $3 billion in revenue in 2013 from prison operations.

Since its inception in 1994, GEO Group shares are up 2,388 percent, according to Google Finance.

In a recent episode of HBO’s Last Week Tonight, John Oliver’s takedown of the prison industry was summed up by this eye-opening discovery: the prison population has become so large that “Sesame Street” felt compelled to have its puppets play out a “parent in prison” narrative.”

Source: Edwood Remsberg | Image Bank | Getty Images

Free at last?

While the U.S. prison population has ballooned since the 1970s, the 2009 peak has been followed by a slight decrease.

Outgoing U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder even cited a decrease in the federal prison population as one of his accomplishments. The federal prison population has dropped by roughly 4,800 inmates in the past year, the first decline in three decades, and Holder predicted that by fiscal 2016, the population would drop by 10,000 inmates, or the equivalent of six federal prisons.

The total U.S. federal and state prison population decreased after the 2009 peak for three years through 2012, but it ticked back up again (0.3 percent) in 2013, with the state prison population increasing for the first time since 2009.

At the end of 2013, state and federal prisons held 1,574,700 individuals, an increase of 4,300 from 2012.

Revenue sharing with states

Aside from prisoners, the business has another beneficiary: state coffers. In return for doing business, JPay gives the state a cut of its revenue. For example, if JPay charges $3 for a money transfer, the state might get 50 cents, depending on each individual agreement. (The company charges $1.45 to $24.95 per transfer, depending on the amount of money sent.)

"Government agencies can and will accept a portion of the revenue as an incentive to put the program in, because if there's any agency or department that's strapped for cash or for money, it's corrections," Shapiro said.

JPay's fees vary based on such factors as how much the state takes and fees paid to third parties like banking software companies, Shapiro said.

States vary as to what services they will allow businesses to sell to inmates "It really depends on the 'political mood," Shapiro said.

At the North Dakota State Penitentiary, where over 50 percent of the population uses JPay in some form, all of the company's services are allowed, Warden Colby Braun said.

"It's a way to improve what they have and improve their lives, that's the whole focus of this," Braun said.

Is it right to profit from prisoners?

Critics, though, question a model where states and companies benefit on the backs of prisoners and their families.

Jack Donson, who worked at the Federal Bureau of Prisons for 22 years, doesn't think so.

"I always say we're a third-world correctional system in the United States." Donson said. "This is a capitalistic society, so I fault more the government—bureaucracies—who are profiting from this as well. The sentence is the punishment."

Shapiro argues that the services help prisoners.

Read MoreFake wine collector gets 10 years

"Our tablets help rehabilitate inmates so they are better equipped for success once released. Technology also plays a role in behavior modification—an inmate that is engaged during the day is less likely to act out in violence," he said.

Shapiro also claims that the state's cut of JPay's business goes back to the inmates, whether in the form of recreational activities or building infrastructure to support educational programs.

Donson, who now runs a private prison consulting business and serves as an advocate for prison reform, disagrees.

"I also think there's an overplaying of, 'Oh, this money goes back to benefit the inmates.' I think that's true, but I don't think it's true to the extent that they portray," he said. "If you would do some due diligence on where that money really goes, I think you would find that not a lot goes directly to inmate programs."

(Another important issue is how these fees impact families outside the prison who pay them. Shapiro says its fees are too low to affect inmates' families. A joint investigation by the Center for Public Integrity and CNBC found that many families are financially burdened trying to keep up with all the costs associated with having a relative or friend behind bars. See that report here.)

Will regulators go after other prison businesses?

Another objection some critics have is that prisoners and their families could easily be gouged by the fees and commissions.

In fact, federal regulators have already gone after some companies, especially those that provide phone services for prisoners.

In 2013, the Federal Communications Commission capped phone rates after an investigation revealed that prisoners were being charged what the agency called "exorbitant" rates.

Exclusive: Inmates use tablets, other tech

Following a hearing on the issue, prison phone company Pay-Tel, CEO Vincent Townsend said that his industry abused the public, and that's why regulators had to ultimately step in.

"I'm not a fan of regulation. But if your industry won't self-correct yourself, then you have no choice—regulators at some point are going to step in," Townsend said. "My counsel to other industries that serve a prison population is you better pay attention to what's the ethical, right, moral … because if you don't treat people fairly, ultimately it's not a long term business plan."

JPay has not been targeted by any Federal probe.

Regardless of the flaws in the system, Shapiro said he is providing valuable services to those behind bars.

"Before JPay came around, that type of customer service did not exist in corrections," Shapiro said.

"It's unfortunate that no one's come out with a better model and if somebody did, that would be fantastic. But nobody has yet."